→ Back to search
1378/05/04 (Solar Hijri) 1999-07-26 (Gregorian)

1378/05/04- Remarks at a Meeting with Students Injured in the Tehran University Dormitory Incident

1378/05/04

Remarks at a Meeting with Students Injured in the Tehran University Dormitory Incident

In the name of God, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.
 
In my opinion, there are two ways of approaching and commenting on events of this kind. The first is the immediate response that arises when one encounters an incident, a tragedy or a crime—and this was a crime. Certain duties fall upon us, although each person has a different responsibility. In a single event, one person may have a duty to lodge a complaint, another to investigate and another to provide assistance. Everyone has responsibilities in the face of events. Looking at an event in order to determine one’s practical duty is one approach. I hope everyone who is in some way connected with this incident has taken that approach, or will do so if they have not already.
 
An incident like this certainly involves offenders as well as causes and circumstances. The offenders must be dealt with, and those causes and circumstances identified and addressed. That is one aspect of responding to it. Of course, it was a very bitter incident, in several respects. First, it affected not just one person but a group of people. There is a great difference between harming one individual—beating someone, for example—and harming a group. Second, it involved students, a valuable segment of society, the select sons and daughters of our national family. Indeed, students are among the chosen children of the great family called the Iranian nation. Naturally, an incident involving them wounds and distresses us more deeply. Third, it happened on university premises, since the dormitory is part of the university environment and the university residential complex belongs to students. Fourth, it happened at night, during a time of rest, in what should have been the secure environment of their home.
 
Each of these circumstances, taken separately, is enough to make the incident genuinely appalling, bitter and ugly. It truly was bitter. Naturally, responsibilities fall on everyone, and various people are taking action. As recently as today I again stressed to a senior official who was here that the matter must be pursued so that, God willing, we can fulfill the responsibilities incumbent upon us.
 
That is one perspective on the incident. Let us move beyond it, because ever since it happened people have constantly discussed it. When I spoke, I too spoke about the same matter, as did others. As you know, there are different perspectives: some ask who was responsible; others say it was a conspiracy. Despite their differences, all those opinions examine the event from this first perspective.
 
There is another perspective on events: whenever something happens to an individual or to a group to which that individual belongs, a person can respond in a way that turns an apparently bitter event into something fortunate and blessed, or use even an apparently pleasant event in a way that makes it unfortunate and harmful. People differ in their mental and spiritual response. Take an earthquake, for example. It is a terribly bitter experience. Perhaps you have been in places struck by earthquakes. I have visited many such places. These events are heartbreaking and can bring one to tears. Yet there are two possible responses: one that turns the earthquake into a positive, constructive blessing for those affected, and another that makes it wholly destructive. Those directly affected can respond in either way. Of course, if they are uneducated, uninformed or unfamiliar with such insights, others must help them learn how to make the second, beneficial kind of use of the experience. But if they are thoughtful, intelligent, educated and aware—as students generally are—they can draw spiritual and moral benefit from it themselves, making it a source of blessing rather than misfortune.
 
Consider the earthquake I mentioned. Imagine a young man who has lost his father, mother or relatives and whose house has collapsed. The earthquake can lead him to say: “Everything I had was taken from me; I cannot regard what exists as permanent. I must rely on my own strength and the vitality God has placed within me to make up for my losses. Just as something that existed can disappear in an instant, what does not exist can also be brought into existence, either instantly or gradually. So I shall create something for myself.” If an earthquake victim draws that conclusion, or if the affected community develops that spirit and asks, “Our town has been destroyed; how can we rebuild it?” that is excellent. I witnessed the earthquakes in Ferdows, Tabas—ten years apart—Rudbar and Qazvin, and other earthquakes. The people differed. Some genuinely had that attitude. As soon as disaster struck, they felt they must work, recreate what they had lost and repair the damage. That feeling became the origin of a new kind of progress they had never previously experienced. Before, each had lived comfortably in a town pursuing their ordinary work. Afterwards they became energetic, active people who started from nothing and built things for themselves.
 
When you look back ten years later, an earthquake that was so bitter may, through that kind of response, have become a source of blessing and growth for those people. It was bitter at first, but ultimately proved beneficial. Had it not occurred, they might have carried on their ordinary lives in inactivity or laziness, remaining ordinary people. Instead, by their own hands, determination and decisions, they traveled a difficult road and accomplished challenging work. But suppose the same victims respond differently, saying: “Wonderful! We used to go to our shops to work every day, but now people bring truckloads of supplies to us. We can sleep late and wait for food to be brought to our tent. If they give too little, we can quarrel and demand more.” Sadly, I have seen a few people living that way. With that response, the earthquake becomes a genuinely disastrous event for them.
 
Now replace the earthquake in this example with wealth. Imagine a young person in an affluent family with no difficulties: a bed for sleeping, a desk for studying, a car for travel, air conditioning for the heat, heating for the cold, meals brought at lunchtime, and everything else. If these comfortable conditions make that young person lazy, idle and unambitious, never discovering their own abilities, then that comfortable life is a calamity. Unless they correct their condition later, they will experience misery and an unhappy life. The subsequent decision and the conclusion drawn from an event can therefore be decisive for a person.
 
Now an incident has happened to you, and it was certainly bitter. Some were hurt more severely, others less, but all were harmed. At the very least, people were frightened and retreated into their rooms, only to have doors kicked open, some students awakened violently or insulted. In any case, violence was used. Yes, it was a bitter incident—a crime. But it is not among the very worst calamities; that is clear. For someone like me, who bears responsibility within the system, it may be more bitter than an earthquake because of the human agency and other considerations. That is not what I am discussing now. From the standpoint of you who suffered, it may not rank among the very worst events. Consider bombings, for example, experienced by people under bombardment. Nevertheless, this was a bitter incident.
 
How will you use what happened? What ideas and conclusions will you draw from it? Your answer will affect your future. One can derive many trains of thought from this event, each of which may have a particular effect on the life of the person adopting it. Suppose someone reflects that, on the path of study and toward the level of excellence we seek, every kind of unexpected and uncalculated incident may occur. You did not expect this event at all; you had no notion that anything like it might happen. Along the path of study, knowledge and achievement—or, more broadly, along the road of life—events occur that nobody has calculated or foreseen. Nobody can blame you for failing, when you went to sleep in the dormitory, to consider that someone might kick down your door. That was simply not a reasonably foreseeable possibility. Likewise, a person sleeping at home in a city relatively far from the border did not imagine that an aircraft might suddenly arrive at midnight and drop a bomb, and that the bomb would happen to strike the roof above them and kill their wife, children and relatives. Such events are entirely unexpected. There are thousands of kinds of unexpected events in life, beyond anything we can imagine.
 
One initial conclusion is that we should make ourselves spiritually firm and strong and prepare to face life’s many events. How can we do that? Naturally, to withstand physical blows, one strengthens the body. What should we do about events that affect the soul? I believe we should strengthen our faith. We must firmly attach our faith to a fundamental, reassuring and secure point of support. With such faith, we will not succumb to despair at any stage of life. Do you understand? What truly destroys a person is despair. It makes one unable to take another step and extinguishes all one’s strength. When a person feels unable to continue, they are undone. What prevents you from feeling that everything is over and you have reached the end of the road? Belief in a source, in a point of support. This may be faith in God and the unseen—which is best—or faith in a human ideal, as some people have. Some believe in a particular idea even though it is not wholly divine. In a sense every ideal is spiritual, since it belongs to the mind and spirit, but it is not necessarily God-centered.
 
The virtue of a God-centered ideal is that you can have a reciprocal relationship with the one on whom you rely. It is a real being, a reality that hears what you say and has something to say in reply. Dear ones, know that when a heart establishes a relationship with God, it is certainly not a one-way relationship but a two-way one. To people far removed from divine knowledge, attention and spiritual attachments, it may seem strange to say that God speaks to a person. Yes, He does, and you will feel it. You can feel it; it is not far away. “The journey toward You is short in distance” (1). God is very near to anyone who moves toward Him.
 
Suppose you know the meaning and translation of the words recited in prayer. If, from the beginning, a person attends to those meanings without becoming distracted by anything in the outer world or within their mind, and genuinely speaks to God—just as I speak to you now, and throughout my speech you do not leave my mind for a moment because I am continually addressing you—that is sufficient. This is not an excessive demand; we have been asked for no more than that. When you talk to a friend or an ordinary person, you attend to them continually, understand what you are saying and know what you intend. Speak the same way when addressing God in prayer. If you begin a prayer in this way and sustain that state of attention, partway through you will suddenly feel your heart receiving something from somewhere, apprehending a feeling. Something is speaking to you. Your heart becomes perceptive, and you receive precisely the answer you need. At first it may be somewhat indistinct. You young people have radiant hearts, however, and this is much easier for you than for us. You can perceive the divine message sooner and more clearly. God speaks to you and answers you, and you feel that reply within your hearts.
 
That is the difference between this point of reliance and the imagined or real supports others possess and sometimes use. Other supports may be useful in certain circumstances, but they lack these qualities. I say that whatever future you have chosen or hoped for—whether to become a doctor, professor, entrepreneur, politician or ruler, or any other imagined or desired future—if you wish to reach it, you should strengthen faith within your heart, and especially enlightened faith. Even faith without clear knowledge is useful, as in the case of an ordinary person who believes without much understanding; it too can work wonders. But when faith is combined with knowledge, its effect is multiplied a thousandfold. You young people can achieve that.
 
Life contains incidents. This was one kind; another may arise within a person. Some incidents have no guilty party at all. In this incident, your good fortune is that offenders exist and, God willing, they will be punished. People usually look for someone to blame whenever something happens; even if someone knocks over a glass, they ask why it was put there. Yet many incidents harm us when there is nobody to blame, nobody whose collar we can seize. Life contains many such events. Sometimes they alter our course, sow doubts in our hearts and make the paths before us appear blocked. If you wish to avoid that, and always retain your energy, willpower, strength and firm resolve to follow the right paths in life, cultivate that conscious faith within yourselves—both faith and understanding. Understanding must be acquired from books and by listening to knowledgeable people. As for faith, I believe you can increase it by putting into practice the measure of faith you already possess. Faith is an extraordinary treasure. Praise be to God, all of you are faithful young people raised in believing families. Put your existing faith into practice by joining it to righteous deeds: refrain from sin, perform virtuous acts as well as possible, and especially avoid sins arising from selfishness and acts of injustice against others. Avoid improper words about other people; even try to clear your mind of certain thoughts. These are increasingly righteous actions. Such deeds strengthen the faith you already have. When faith is accompanied by action, it continually increases day by day. When the knowledge obtained from wise people, books and moral counsel is also joined to righteous action, knowledge itself increases. “Whoever is mindful of God, He will make for them a way out” (2), “and provide for them from where they do not expect; and whoever puts their trust in God, He is sufficient for them” (3). “Whoever believes in God, He guides their heart” (4). It was this last verse that I had in mind. Mindfulness and self-watchfulness themselves guide the heart and make faith firmer.
 
I am very happy to have seen you dear young people. The anxiety I felt about the incident—which I still feel—and the sorrow and grief it caused us will, God willing, be somewhat relieved by seeing you. Your open, energetic faces bring consolation. I emphasize: please do not allow that spirit to be lost, especially this dear young man here (5). Hearing about your eye caused me great distress. I had not heard that detail, although I had heard a great deal about the incident and had been told that one of the students who ranked first in the university entrance examination had been injured. They had not told me that your eye was damaged in this way. I was deeply saddened. May God, by Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, compensate you in the best possible way.
 
6) A student: “Greetings to Your Eminence. At the moment we came to see you and you said, ‘My heart has been wounded,’ we truly wished for death a thousand times. I say this with complete certainty. Sir, on behalf of all the students and those who wanted to come but could not, I convey their greetings to you. Everyone asked for your prayers and said, ‘Convey our greetings to the Leader.’ We apologize to Your Eminence with all our hearts for the fact that some people among us, and in our name, insulted you. Sir, do not think that we remained silent. We apologize wholeheartedly. We hope your good prayers accompany us on our way. We promise to stand by our pledge to you and to the Imam until our last breath. Through you, we say to His Holiness Mahdi that we are standing firm and ask him to help all our officials.”
 
“May God protect you. You are my dear children; that is how I feel about you. May God always be with you.”
 
7) Another student: “What our brother said expressed everyone’s feelings. I would add one thing. When they beat us, they shouted ‘Ya Zahra,’ ‘Ya Husayn,’ and some shouted ‘Death to opponents of the Guardianship of the Jurist.’ Why do they use religion’s name? When we heard your words in the news, the attack itself may have been a dagger in our hearts, but your words ‘It wounded my heart’ felt like a still larger dagger. Those words hurt us even more. Some who were exposed to tear gas may also have said insulting things, but in that atmosphere they did not understand what they were saying. Many regret it now and never intended those words. Please forgive them and pray for a climate where concern for religion comes first, not exploiting religion and promoting oneself in its name. We have always tried to calm these gatherings, but perhaps our own actions upset you. Please forgive us too.”
 
“May you succeed. Your statement that they entered in religion’s name, invoking ‘Ya Zahra’ and those other sacred names, deserves some careful thought. We should examine what motives might have existed. I simply cannot believe that someone would enter a student’s room, beat them and say, ‘You are an enemy of Zahra or of the leadership, so take this beating!’ I find it unbelievable. If we can identify those who uttered such words—surely not all of them did, but some did—I suspect another motive may be discovered. What you said about causing people to become distrustful is true and very important. Who should uncover it, when it might be uncovered, and whether the investigation succeeds are separate questions. Now let us return to that second perspective on the incident: say to yourselves that we must act so that this young student does not turn away from religion because of a malicious or ignorant act. This is what you and I must truly feel responsible for. Yes, do not let them turn away from religion, because turning away for this reason is among the bitterest things. I have sometimes told stories illustrating this point in speeches, but I am a little tired now and do not feel able to continue. If you come another time, remind me to tell you a story Rumi relates about driving someone away from religion through this same method of invoking Husayn and Zahra. It is a way of alienating people from religion. Apparently such things existed even in Rumi’s time. Some do them deliberately, while others then did them unintentionally. Now, as faithful, righteous and enlightened young people, what is your duty toward those affected? It is not to allow them to be driven away from religion. Someone may alienate people from faith by this method; you, who think differently, should not allow it. Ask God for success, and He will grant it.”
 
Peace be upon you, and God’s mercy and blessings.
 
 
1) Al-Iqbal by Sayyid ibn Tawus, vol. 1, p. 158.
 
2) Surah At-Talaq, verse 2.
 
3) Surah At-Talaq, verse 3.
 
4) Surah At-Taghabun, verse 11.
 
5) Refers to a student who had suffered an injury to one eye.
 
6) Remarks by one of the students.
 
7) Remarks by one of the students.

The July 1999 university dormitory incident