I have a question about “social justice.” Despite your remarks over the past several years, this issue has become entangled in political games and has made little progress toward the goal you described. Is it not time to address it in a principled manner, examine individuals’ assets, begin with government officials, and gradually extend the process throughout society?
That is an excellent suggestion, easy to make but extremely difficult to implement. As soon as action is taken concerning certain officials, they naturally begin complaining, protesting, and raising an outcry. Sometimes obstacles are even placed in the way of the whole undertaking, preventing it from going ahead. I firmly believe that the issue of “social justice” must be pursued—there is no doubt about this, and I have said so repeatedly. However, I am not the person responsible for pursuing it; the Judiciary and government agencies must do so. Some aspects must be addressed through good laws, others through implementation, and still others through inspections by superior and higher-level bodies—that is, government agencies overseeing their subordinate departments. In any event, I agree with the writer of this letter on this matter and hope that progress will be made.
Of course, some work is being done; it is not as though nothing is happening. A while ago, I asked the Judiciary about this very issue. They provided reports, and measures are being taken, but the pace of progress does not satisfy even me, let alone you, who are young and idealistic.
What is the practical solution to the country's economic problems—problems such as employment, housing, and the like? Is there such a thing as an “Islamic economy”? Please explain, if possible.
Yes, there is such a concept as an “Islamic economy,” and books have been written about it. Some economic measures taken by the government since the beginning of the Revolution—including banking operations and certain other activities—have been based on that same “Islamic economy.” In my view, the country's economic problems can be solved, and acceptable plans have been prepared for that purpose. Last year, after considerable effort, the President and a group of colleagues drew up a plan known as the “Economic Restructuring Plan.” It was a good plan. They brought it to me as well, and I approved it. If that plan is implemented, it will certainly produce good results. It has, however, been incorporated into the current Five-Year Plan. If the Five-Year Plan conforms to the policies that we have specifically formulated, announced, and developed through extensive consultation and work, I have no doubt that tangible results will be seen within five years. I am not saying that every problem will be completely resolved, but tangible results will certainly be achieved—provided those policies are followed precisely. We have instructed both the government and Parliament to ensure that, to the extent practicable—and we believe that all or nearly all of them are practicable—these policies are reflected in the provisions of the plans.
What are the characteristics of a good newspaper? Which of the publications currently available do you consider closest to these characteristics?
First, it is not a reasonable expectation that I should name a particular newspaper and tell you, for example, that I consider it close to these standards. You should choose for yourselves. I do not think searching for and selecting a good newspaper places an excessively heavy responsibility on a student. We do have good newspapers. As for what their characteristics are, that is clear: a newspaper that aims to provide sound information, sound and insightful analysis, substantial content, and coverage of the concerns of the public or the majority of people, using effective artistic methods. In my view, that would be a good newspaper. Some of our newspapers are like that; others are not, and some are very bad!
Please explain the Special Court for the Clergy and its status.
The Special Court for the Clergy is a proper, appropriate, lawful, and necessary court. Of course, some people stir up controversy and raise objections, but those objections are neither valid nor justified. This court was established appropriately and at the right time, and it has performed important and fundamental work. Like every other social group, the clergy are vulnerable to misconduct. At the same time, the particular position and standing of this group require a court with the courage, boldness, and ability to bring a cleric to trial, question him, and demand answers. When the person conducting the trial is himself a cleric—knowing what the accused knows—he is naturally better able to try him. All of these considerations were taken into account. Some people claim that this court did not exist during Imam Khomeini's time. That is nonsense. The court dates back to Imam Khomeini's time; he established it and attached importance to it. This court has done important work. It is therefore a good court, and its status is lawful. Of course, Imam Khomeini once said something not specifically about this court but about the Judiciary as a whole: one feature of the Judiciary and its courts is that at least half the people are dissatisfied with them, because half the people appearing before the courts are either those who have been convicted or supporters of those convicted, and naturally they end up dissatisfied. The Special Court for the Clergy is no exception.
Do you consider the Special Court for the Clergy's performance to be fair?
Its actions are lawful. I cannot honestly pass judgment on every court and say whether its conduct is one hundred percent fair. But as far as appearances indicate, we have not seen anything unfair on its part. Its performance is not bad. If a case is brought forward in which it has acted contrary to the law or justice, that can certainly be investigated. But to my knowledge, no; I have observed no unfair action by this court.
Is the existence of such a court consistent with the Constitution?
Yes, it is entirely consistent with the Constitution. This is not the occasion for a full explanation, but if it were otherwise, it certainly could not have continued operating over all these years—it has now been working for sixteen or seventeen years.
How much longer will you remain silent in the face of political factions' efforts to undermine unity? Of course, I know you admonish them. But now that, by God's grace, the respected President has succeeded in showing the world Iran's peace-loving face, would it not be better to create an atmosphere within the country in which the government, which is serving the people, can implement its programs? If we are Muslims, and if our factions truly care about Iran, would it not be better to strengthen Islam's capabilities rather than undermine one another?
That is absolutely right. We should say to the brother or sister who wrote this question, “You have spoken the very words in my heart.” Fortunately, I have not remained silent about the matter you mention, nor will I. I have told these political factions and organizations many times, both in meetings held specifically with them and sometimes in joint meetings attended by several groups. In order to encourage them to act, I have also spoken about it in public gatherings—including Friday prayers and public addresses—so that public sentiment would exert pressure on them to pursue unity, solidarity, and cooperation. Of course, by unity I do not mean that everyone should become a single organization. No, I mean that they should cooperate, stop obstructing one another, and move forward. I can see that our student friend shares this feeling, and that is precisely what I want as well. I want everyone to make this same demand of political groups. I believe some steps have been taken and some useful things have been done. God willing, they will go further.
What is your opinion about putting genuine supporters of the Revolution on trial? [Two people have been named here, but I will not read their names at all, whether they have been mentioned favorably or unfavorably.] Is the present course of events befitting an Islamic system?
Look, it is illogical to say that someone must not be tried simply because they were among the supporters of the Revolution. A supporter of the Revolution should conduct himself in such a way that his actions are not considered criminal under the laws of that very Revolution, so he will not be brought to court, or, if he is brought to court, he will be acquitted. Otherwise, suppose a person is a genuine supporter of the Revolution but also commits a crime. We cannot say that he must not be tried merely because he is a genuine supporter of the Revolution. That is not sound reasoning. As for the two people named by the questioner—their position, whether they are genuine supporters of the Revolution, whether they were in the past and still are, whether one is and the other is not—that is not my concern here. But assuming that someone is a supporter of the Revolution, that must not prevent the judicial authorities from taking action against him if, in their judgment, he commits an offense.
Why is decisive action not taken against the aristocratic lifestyles that have developed among many national officials? Why is the constitutional provision concerning examination of government officials' assets not being implemented rigorously?
Actually, the Constitution does not require a detailed examination of the assets of every government official. It applies only to certain officials—such as the Leader, the President, and some others—who must declare their assets when they assume office and again when they leave, so it can be established what they have acquired and how much their assets have increased during that period. This constitutional provision is being implemented. I personally completed these forms on several occasions, when I assumed the presidency, when my term ended, and when I took up my subsequent responsibility, and submitted them to the Judiciary. Others do the same. However, the question about aristocratic lifestyles is a very valid one. If I truly see that this concern, demand, and attitude exist among young university students, I will sincerely thank God. You should understand that the inclination toward aristocratic living cannot be remedied simply through legislation, courts, interrogation, or similar measures. The problem is much more difficult than that. This is among those issues that must be rejected by the general atmosphere of the country—the people's feelings, their demands, or, more precisely, the public culture—if it is to be remedied. Those who aspire to an aristocratic lifestyle, who long to eat, dress, live, and conduct themselves like the aristocracy and far removed from the ordinary lives of average people, try, among other things, to instill in people the idea that such a life is desirable and valuable. That was the situation before the Revolution. Before the Revolution, the more government officials appeared amid ceremony, pomp, arrogance, self-importance, and extravagant clothing, the more some ordinary people admired them! Public culture had been shaped that way. After the Revolution, this was reversed. Consequently, even people inclined toward aristocratic ways avoided them for fear of public opinion. Today, however, efforts are gradually being made to reverse the situation once again. In my view, aristocratic living is a blight on a country, and aristocratic living among officials is a double blight. For when the aristocrats of the world spend their own money—whether it was lawfully or unlawfully acquired is their affair—they are indulging themselves with their own wealth. But when officials live like aristocrats, they spend the people's money, not their own. This problem must be corrected through public attitudes, writing, speaking, and promoting this understanding. It must become part of the culture. It cannot be resolved through special courts, trials, and similar measures.
Does your support for the government and for the President personally mean that you endorse the policies in which the government and the President believe and which they implement?
I have supported the President and will continue to support him. That is my duty, and I must do so. I support the government as a whole as well. Of course, there are members of the government whose methods and policies I do not approve of. They themselves and the government leadership know this. The public may not know—and there has been no need for the public to know—but those who needed to know have known. I have had criticisms, and whenever necessary I have expressed them to those concerned. Where circumstances required it, I have also been firm and taken strong action to bring about corrections. But when you ask whether my support for the government and the President means accepting the policies they “believe in,” I do not know what this “believe in” means! What we can observe is their actual performance and approach, and I see no objection to their carrying out their work. Of course, people are not all alike. Their weaknesses and strengths, capabilities and abilities differ, just as their personal preferences and ways of speaking differ. Some people defend a truth in one way, while another person defending that same truth speaks differently. A discerning person must look for the substance and go beyond the outer forms. If you bear this in mind, I see no problem.
If there is a problem with policies or performance, should we voice it? How can we do so without being accused of opposing your statements in support of the government?
I have never prevented criticism or prohibited anyone from criticizing. Sound and well-intentioned criticism does no harm, but it must not turn into destructive attacks. Some people criticize in a manner that amounts to destruction, and that is not advisable. If someone carries a heavy responsibility in the country and we expect him to accomplish certain things—to put the economy in order, for example—can we reasonably expect him to do so if we do not strengthen him, and if we fail to cover an occasional weakness? Can we still hope that what we want will be achieved and that he will fulfill his duties? In my view, everyone has a duty to help and support the country's officials, of course as long as they follow the straight path of Islam and Imam Khomeini. If anyone departs from that straight path, whoever he may be, he is not worthy of support. There is no difference here: everyone from top to bottom is subject to the same rule, including myself. If, God forbid, I too depart from that correct path of Islam, the people are under no obligation to support or obey me. Of course, mistakes and differences of opinion may sometimes occur. Such differences must not cause us to withdraw our support from national officials and those responsible for various departments. No, we should support them.
My dear friends, you should also know that the country's strength today lies in the bond between the government and the people. There is nothing quite like it anywhere else in the world. I say this with knowledge and awareness. Even in democratic countries, you do not find the kind of atmosphere you see here—and fortunately there are many such examples in this country—where an official sits down and speaks warmly and informally with the people, without their being afraid of him or his feeling fear or estrangement toward them. This too is a blessing of religion and Islam. Otherwise, those governments that imagined and claimed themselves to be popular governments—though they were irreligious and atheistic—had barriers separating them from their people that were much thicker than those elsewhere! Thus, this bond between the government and the people exists thanks to religion and Islam. It must not be lost; it is immensely valuable. The relationship between government officials and the people, the people's support for officials, and the officials' concern and affection for the people are all extremely valuable.
Does depriving citizens of their natural right to stand for election through approbatory supervision not undermine people's confidence in the foundations of the system?
My answer is no, it does not, because approbatory supervision is prescribed by law, and no one should object to compliance with the law. This supervision by the Guardian Council is carried out according to law and is based on the Constitution. Its foundations and roots are in the Constitution, and it is also affirmed and established in ordinary legislation. This supervision does not target ordinary citizens; its purpose is to prevent an unsuitable, harmful, or bad person from entering a sensitive institution. Approbatory supervision is not limited to Parliament; it applies to the presidency as well. Just imagine a glib, deceitful person, supported from abroad, with abundant money, who presents himself attractively in various ways, comes here, stands as a candidate, wins a majority, and becomes President. What would happen to the country?! The purpose of approbatory supervision is precisely to prevent people who, under the country's laws, are not qualified for such sensitive positions—whether in Parliament, the presidency, or other bodies where such supervision applies, including the Assembly of Experts—from entering those sensitive institutions. Approbatory supervision is a good thing, not a bad thing. Those who criticize and object claim that the Guardian Council approves or rejects candidates according to their political inclinations. That is not true. The members of the Guardian Council themselves have always denied it. And to the extent that I have personally observed their work, I have not had that impression either. Of course, someone may occasionally misunderstand a matter or reach an incorrect conclusion; that is a separate issue. But the underlying basis is the law.
For some time there has been discussion of principles and preferences, and certain fallacies have arisen in this regard. Please explain the criterion for distinguishing principles from preferences and drawing a boundary between them. How can principles be identified?
Principles cannot be confused with different preferences in various fields. Principles are the intellectual foundations of a system and a governmental order. Islam is a principle; independence is a principle; the religious system is a principle; observance of Islamic laws is a principle; and the overall orientation of the nation and country toward greater religious commitment and the development of a fully Islamic society is a principle. Principles are matters of this kind. Preferences concern, for example, a person's being on good terms with one individual and not another, or liking one person while another dislikes that person. In economics there are matters more substantial than mere preferences, but they still are not principles. Suppose one person believes in a policy of “economic adjustment,” while another opposes it and favors a different policy. Such differences go beyond mere personal preference, but they must not be confused with principles. When a person with a particular political preference and approach holds office, he acts accordingly; someone else takes office and acts according to another approach. But the principles always remain intact. Consider the period beginning with my presidency, when one person headed the government and was then succeeded by another, and the period following my presidency, when yet another person headed the government. Although political and economic preferences have varied considerably, the intellectual foundations throughout this period—belief in Islam, belief in Imam Khomeini, belief in the Islamic system, and belief in the people's central role in society—have all remained in place. These convictions do not change merely because governments come and go. Therefore, the two cannot be confused.
In your opinion, is the concept of guardianship sometimes defined and defended poorly? And do some people who claim to support and follow the guardianship not behave badly?
Yes; in fact, it is very often defended poorly. Some defend it badly, and others may act badly. That certainly happens and cannot be denied. Similarly, many people who support belief in God and are counted among the religious people of the world behave badly. Many supporters of the Islamic faith behave badly. Such misconduct can and does occur everywhere. But the fundamental point is that when someone acts badly in the name of supporting the guardianship, religion, Islam, the Islamic system, or a particular individual, we must not attribute that person's wrongdoing to the truth or principle he claims to support. We must not transfer his wrongdoing to that truth. Rather, we should say that the principle retains its standing, while the person has acted badly. Sometimes, we see people with improper motives deliberately confuse the two. Because a person supports religion or some other truth and has behaved badly, these people sometimes insult the truth or cause he supports. That is certainly wrong.
Usually, when we attend a question-and-answer session, the questions we answer amount to perhaps one-tenth of those we leave unanswered. I think that is the case now as well. Questions are still being submitted, and I would certainly like to be able to answer them later. On some occasions, we have taken the questions away, answered them afterward, and made the answers available. Unfortunately, my time is extremely limited. If I could, I would hold a meeting like this with students once a month or once every two months. But my available time is very limited and my work and responsibilities are very demanding; unfortunately, I rarely have the opportunity. Otherwise, I would like to answer all these questions. God willing, we will try to ask several colleagues in the office to sit down and review the questions, set aside those that are repetitive, draft answers to the remaining questions, and submit them for my consideration. Then the answers can be returned so that our student friends can read all of them. In any case, I was pleased that today's meeting took place. I shall offer a few prayers, and I ask you to join in these prayers with your pure and warm hearts, saying amen, so that God willing, Almighty God will answer them.
O Lord! We invoke Your names and attributes of majesty and beauty and beseech You to encompass us, our nation, and our country in Your guidance and mercy. O Lord! Do not deprive us of Islam and the Qur’an. O Lord! Draw our society closer to Islam and the Islamic system with every passing day. O Lord! For the sake of Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, we beseech You to extend Your special help and grace to faithful, devoted, motivated, and virtuous young people—young people who mobilize and prepare themselves in God's cause to discharge heavy responsibilities in His path. Keep them steadfast and protect them from the evils of human and jinn devils. O Lord! Make our universities more flourishing, more abundant, and more blessed day by day. O Lord! Remove the hardships of this nation. O Lord! Make the sacred heart of the Master of the Age (may our souls be sacrificed for him) pleased and satisfied with us, and count us among his soldiers.
Peace be upon you, and God's mercy and blessings.