1379/06/20
Remarks at the Beginning of the Advanced Jurisprudence Lesson for the Academic Year 1379
In the name of Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.
Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds. May Allah bless our master Muhammad and his pure family, and may His curse be upon all their enemies.
Before beginning our discussions of jurisprudence, as usual, let us relate a hadith from the noble book Tuhaf al-Uqul, and then turn to our remarks. “Among the counsels of Abu Abdullah, peace be upon him, to Muhammad ibn Nu'man al-Ahwal—Mu'min al-Taq—(1): O son of Nu'man, do not seek knowledge for three purposes.” First, “to show it off”: to engage in ostentation and display to others that you are learned. Do not pursue knowledge for self-display. Second, “nor to boast of it”: do not acquire it in order to boast. Apparently, the first means showing off before ordinary people, whereas the second means boasting among scholars: entering a gathering of learned people to flaunt the fact that you, too, know this or that. Do not study for this either. Third, “nor to dispute with it”: do not learn merely for contentious argument. Disputation means quarrelling and obstinacy in debate. The Holy Quran says, “Will you dispute with him concerning what he saw?” (2), meaning: will you argue with him over what he saw with his own eyes, referring to the events of the Night Journey and Ascension? Thus, according to this hadith, the Imam says not to seek knowledge for these three ends. Knowledge is really to be sought for understanding and action, not for ostentation, gaining prestige or arguing.
“And do not abandon it for three reasons”: do not forsake knowledge for these three motives. First, “a desire for ignorance.” Some people want not to know; they seem hostile to knowledge itself. Do not be surprised: some refuse to listen to an idea, or forbid others to hear it, so that knowledge does not arise in them. Some refuse themselves; others induce others to refuse, out of hostility to that knowledge. The expression here is unqualified: “a desire for ignorance.” Does the word “knowledge” refer to the knowledge traditionally mentioned by the Imams, namely religious learning and understanding of religion? Possibly. On that reading it means wanting to remain ignorant of religious knowledge. But it might also mean knowledge generally, without restriction to a particular kind. Do not abandon any field of knowledge just because you prefer ignorance of it. Having no time or reason to study it is another matter; hostility to knowledge itself is not an acceptable reason. Second, “disinclination toward knowledge”: do not neglect learning through indifference or lack of interest. Do not regard knowing something as so unimportant that you disdain to learn it. Third, “embarrassment before people”: do not abandon learning because you are ashamed in front of others. Some imagine studying is beneath their station, even though listening, sitting down and learning would elevate them. Yet embarrassment makes them unwilling to learn, as though they considered themselves too exalted to be students. Do not forsake knowledge for these three reasons. Lacking time, money or a teacher is a different matter and may prevent someone from studying; but it should not be because of apathy, preference for ignorance or embarrassment. Then the Imam said: “Knowledge kept hidden is like a lamp with a cover over it.” Knowledge concealed rather than communicated, taught or put into practice is like a lamp covered over: it is useless, and its light reaches no one.
This is a hadith from Abu Abdullah, peace be upon him, addressed to Mu’min al-Taq. In our edition of Tuhaf al-Uqul it appears on page 313.
Let me also say a few words today on the occasion of the beginning of the academic year in the Islamic seminaries. About studying in seminaries and their other affairs, I and others have raised many points and offered reminders. Hardly anything on these matters has not already been said. Yet speaking, hearing and discussing are one thing; turning them into a culture and a recognized need, and making those in charge pursue them, is quite another. This second development has not yet occurred.
Today I want to raise one or two matters concerning scholarship and the seminaries that seem to me more necessary than the others, although all the matters that have been discussed—and perhaps repeated—are necessary.
One matter is planning in the seminaries. I once said in a gathering of students and scholars that every small institution—an office or a university—plans its work. A seminary, which is an immense gathering of great scholars and researchers in numerous disciplines—jurisprudence, Quranic interpretation, principles of jurisprudence, theology, philosophy and the other branches taught there—must have a permanent planning institution. In terms of the caliber of its people, a seminary like Qom cannot really be compared with ordinary academic organizations. It has eminent personalities and researchers, alongside so many young people, among whom there are numerous learned, perceptive, talented researchers. An institution with such breadth, depth, size and quality needs continuous planning. Of course, things have changed since I first said this: today real progress can be seen in most or all seminaries, especially Qom. They have administrative structures and engage in planning. But the extent of their planning is not commensurate with this immense scale and capacity.
If we want to determine what planning is needed for Qom with all its capacities, we must look at the world and its needs, and at the constant emergence of ideas, theories, statements and questions that relate to seminary disciplines—not to sciences unconnected with the seminary, but to the subjects directly within its competence. New issues are continually raised around the world in ethics, law, philosophy, philosophy of religion and theology. This does not mean that every such idea is correct or important, but that such ideas occupy a vast portion of the mental world of people everywhere.
In today's world of rapid communication, an idea, argument, doubt or proposed solution voiced in one corner of the world can reach the other side within a day or a month. A seminary such as Qom must therefore plan. It should have people prepared to address the varied questions under discussion internationally and people prepared for research, meticulous examination and innovation in subjects already discussed in the seminaries—Islamic philosophy, jurisprudence and the principles of jurisprudence. Some of the matters we discuss under language and other sections of the principles of jurisprudence are now important topics in philosophical circles worldwide. They should undertake research and innovate in those same fields.
There should be groups that examine our teachings comparatively: comparing our jurisprudence with legal systems prevalent in the world; our philosophical discussions with contemporary philosophy elsewhere; and our theological discussions with current theological discourse and what is called the philosophy of religion. They should examine the relationships between them, the disagreements and points of contact, and the new elements that might enrich the subjects commonly discussed among us.
There should also be people devoted to identifying questions being raised internationally that may generate doubts. I have said before that we should not always respond defensively to doubts. We should not sit until an objection appears, hear of it late, allow it to become firmly established in people's minds—especially the young—and only after they tell us about it begin thinking of an answer. That is not right. We should recognize the conditions from which such doubts arise.
We possess exceptionally strong foundations: our theology is robust, our philosophy is lofty, and our jurisprudence contains extraordinary depths not found elsewhere. We should go out to meet new arguments and doubts. This takes planning; it is neither easy nor readily attainable without it. A task that could be accomplished through planning in ten years might take a hundred years without it. One person gradually does some work; by chance someone else later adds to it. How much work is duplicated, how many repetitions and contradictions arise! Planning eliminates these problems. This is extremely important and a fundamental need.
I know that today in Qom there are concerned and devoted people working toward precisely such plans, perhaps on this scale or an even greater one. But until all influential figures in that great seminary—including the eminent religious authorities, senior scholars and distinguished teachers—acknowledge this need and commit themselves to it, it will not be realized. I consider this exceptionally important, because I see in the seminary capable scholars, brilliant talents, outstanding ideas and young people full of youthful energy.
You should know that much of this work belongs especially to youth. Value your youthful energy and determination while you have them. If a planning apparatus of this kind is established in a center like the Qom Seminary, it can gradually bring into a coordinated direction all the talented people elsewhere—for example the many scholars and young people in Tehran engaged in scholarship, government service, the judiciary, executive agencies, ideological-political education, universities and other fields. All these activities could proceed in the proper direction within the scope of one comprehensive plan.
I raise this with you although you are here rather than in Qom, and although I have repeatedly raised it with the senior figures there and with others, because one prerequisite for implementation is that it become a culture and a public demand. Everyone must want it. Today we cannot afford to squander our human, intellectual and scholarly resources. We need them. This is not a time when a learned person can sit in a corner of a town or village, write a book and say, “Someday it will be used.” No. Every intellectual resource should enter the marketplace of ideas, both to develop and be tested and strengthened, and to be put to use. Gone are the days when an elderly woman might store banknotes in a small chest against a rainy day. Now those funds can be invested in productive activity and multiplied in a short time, benefiting both their owner and everyone involved in their circulation. We should not lock our resources away. Anyone with ability or intellectual capital must bring it into active work. By the market for work I do not mean simply taking up a salaried position. Your present occupations, if not all then certainly most of them, are religious duties; some go beyond a collective obligation because there are not enough people to fulfill them. Those duties are necessary, but not sufficient. These talents and minds must be activated, used, strengthened and brought into communication with one another.
Another related point: where there is a vacuum in the presentation of pure, sound and established ideas, confused, adulterated and unsound ideas enter the market. This is natural because customers are always waiting. If authentic, good goods are offered, people will not choose defective goods—provided they can recognize the difference. But when a vacuum appears, counterfeits and forged coins circulate. Unfortunately this is happening in our society today: counterfeit coins and banknotes with attractive appearances, hard for ordinary people to distinguish, but lacking real value.
The market for Islamic thought is like that today. Individuals appear from all directions and pronounce on profound religious and Islamic concepts that require a foundation in the religious sources—a foundation they do not possess. They invent claims: “Islam says this; Islam says that!” And no one in the audience asks where Islam actually says what they claim. They interpret every human concept in Islam's name—freedom, humanity, human rights, justice—without identifying their authority. Which Islam are they talking about?
It is very ugly for people without the necessary competence to venture opinions in such fields. Even assuming their statements have no ulterior motive, they are still ignorant. If political or factional ambitions, self-interest or treacherous motives are involved, the matter is worse. This is an ugly phenomenon in our society, though not one confined to the present. In the past, ignorant people opined about religion in narrow popular circles: someone speaking as a preacher or under another title reached a limited group of ordinary people who accepted his words. Today the difference is that similarly mistaken views about Islamic principles and religious scholarship are delivered in polished forms, presented as new thought and science, though they are neither scientific nor correct. They require scholarly engagement. Government intervention is a separate issue: governments should not intervene in every such matter; doing so is neither appropriate nor effective. But the scholarly arena must be active and vigorous.
Discussions are held about religion itself, the philosophy of religion, doctrinal foundations, Islamic teachings embodied in the Islamic Republic—such as principles of the Constitution—Islamic jurisprudence, and the conduct of the Prophet and the Imams, peace be upon them. Yet these discussions rest neither on history nor hadith, neither on the Quran nor the principles of jurisprudence, neither on recognized religious foundations nor on the disciplined methodology of jurisprudence, which is a profound and delicate craft. They rest on nothing, but are presented in pseudo-intellectual, pseudo-scholarly forms with appealing expressions. Unfortunately, some of those exposed to these ideas are among society's educated and elite; that is the difference from the past. As the verse says:
For when this slippery knowledge waylays someone,
It strikes the knowledgeable even more.
It strikes the informed, obstructs their path, and misleads the elite. Therefore it must be challenged. As I said, the response here is intellectual and scholarly, through brave debate. Of course, if there are political, treacherous or corrupt motives behind such activities, then even when you engage them academically, they may raise an uproar, spread slander and throw mud. Let them do so.
Religious scholars must not remain silent in the face of distortion of religion. An unscientific response is wrong. Shouting that someone has uttered unbelief and excommunicating or denouncing him does not help. Many would welcome exactly that: as soon as they say something, they want to be accused of speaking against Islam, religion or religious leadership, because then they evade scholarly criticism. Genuine academic critique dissects the argument and reveals the falsity of both the claim and its author. This is what must be done.
Of course, if someone says something that falls under established jurisprudential rules and carries a penalty under Islam, I do not intend to prevent that. It is a separate matter for government officials to discharge their legal duties. But that is not the path religious scholars, seminaries and preachers should pursue. Leaders of religious learning must enter the scholarly arena, examine and dissect arguments and demonstrate their errors, with the result that those advocating them are exposed. “Guidance cannot spread except through the channels by which misguidance has spread”: these are the words of the late Sayyid Sharaf al-Din, may God be pleased with him. Guidance should be spread through the very channels used to spread error. Just as an ignorant or malicious person—we are not judging which, for either is possible—enters the arena and presents false, weak and baseless ideas under various attractive labels, scholars and religious teachers must enter and present authentic knowledge and demonstrate why those ideas are wrong.
Do not imagine the seminaries lack people capable of this. Praise be to Allah, many of our young scholars can do it. One person may be a capable researcher but not a good speaker. Another may be skilled at gathering sources and find materials inaccessible to the first. Someone else may know foreign languages and trace an argument to a Western jurist or philosopher whom the researcher cannot read. These people need to be connected and complement one another. Working together, they should put the correct ideas into the hands of someone who can present them attractively, powerfully and rigorously. This is among your duties today, and among the duties of the seminaries and scholars of religion. It must not be neglected; it is very important.
Our young people today need intellectual support: those troubled by doubts, those whose doubts have taken root and led them away from sound belief, and those who are already faithful and observant but need their understanding deepened. The former need to be reached and their doubts dispelled; the latter need their beliefs strengthened, their steadfastness cultivated and their convictions protected.
1) Tuhaf al-Uqul, p. 313.
2) Surat al-Najm, verse 12.