→ Back to search
1379/12/22 (Solar Hijri) 2001-03-12 (Gregorian)

1379/12/22- Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session with Students at Amirkabir University of Technology

1379/12/22

Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session with Students at Amirkabir University of Technology

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful

My dear ones, you are very welcome. I am extremely happy, first to have another opportunity to meet you students and some of our dear professors, and second to be able to set aside this time to answer the questions raised last Tuesday. I was indeed determined that day to return after the prayers and answer your questions as I had promised. But our friends decided, according to their judgment, that the meeting had already gone on a long time and, since I had come to the university at nine o'clock, thought I might be tired. So out of concern and affection they prevented me from returning to answer the questions. In reality I did not feel tired at all that day. In any case I could not fulfill the promise I had made there. I thank God that today the opportunity has arisen to keep that promise.

Our colleagues examined the questions you submitted at that gathering. Some notes express affection toward me; a very small number concern personal requests, which I set aside. There are almost three hundred sheets containing questions. Even if we devoted one minute to each, it would take five hours, so it is not practicable for me to answer them all. Nevertheless, I instructed them not to select among the questions at all. They have placed them here as they came, and I shall pick them up one by one and answer them. I hope to answer a substantial number in the time until the noon call to prayer. I regard all the questions as questions from children to their father. They also cover an extremely broad range: the country, the university, politics, economics—everything can be found among them.

One of the questions I read asked: Why did you promise to come at nine o'clock but arrive at ten-thirty?

My appointment with the students was not at nine o'clock at all. I intended to come to the university at nine, and we were there at precisely that time. But before seeing the students we met the professors. In fact, on entering the university we first stopped at the memorial to its dear martyrs and paid our respects. We then went to the hall displaying selected university research projects, examined them closely and met those responsible for them, which was very informative for me. Afterward we held a meeting with the respected professors. These meetings occupied the time until I came before you. We therefore attended the students' gathering at the time we had arranged. Even on occasions like this I try not to waste a single minute.

Why did some of the students present at that meeting come from other universities?

It was, after all, a student gathering. That was natural, because my visit to this university had been announced beforehand, and some students from other universities decided to come. Looking at the audience, I felt it had a thoroughly student atmosphere and the same sincerity and radiance of student gatherings that I have long known. I am grateful to God for that. We hope today's meeting will be good too.

Given your statements about social justice and the elimination of discrimination and class corruption, why do national officials pay less attention to these principles and fail to apply them even in their private lives, let alone throughout the country?

That is not my impression of the country's senior officials collectively. My impression is that they genuinely wish social justice to be implemented in society. As I have said many times—this is a general assessment, and every rule can have exceptions—they want to work, but may differ in their views on how the work should be done. The assessment of officials' performance has also not been adequately explained to all the people. In all three branches and every sector, much good, positive work has been done that genuinely contributes to social justice. Of course, if you ask whether I am satisfied with this level of achievement, my answer is certainly no. I insist that officials devote all their time, effort, determination and resources to implementing social justice, one of the greatest goals of the Revolution and the major aspirations of our nation. We must move in that direction; God willing, progress in it will become quicker and faster. We must not stop. However far we advance, a distance remains between us and the great aspirations of the Islamic Revolution and Islamic Republic, and so efforts must continue.

Although you know the country's circumstances and understand people's situation well, why do you do nothing? If officials do not listen, why do you not confront them and replace them with competent, trustworthy people who care about the nation? Why should some individuals enjoy ironclad immunity while others do not?

In my view no one has ironclad immunity. Everyone is answerable before the law and for their responsibilities. As for why I do not appoint people myself, the answer is that I act according to the law. Appointing officials is not generally the Leader's responsibility. Most of the country's important sectors are headed by people whose appointment is not within the Leader's authority. The law establishes a procedure, and that procedure must be followed. There is also a legal procedure for complaints about an official who has neglected his duties when that neglect has been established. Parliament responds in one way and the judiciary in another. Affairs must therefore proceed according to law. The country's problems are not so simple, uniform or readily measured at a glance that we can pronounce one official successful and another unsuccessful. Economic, political and cultural affairs are complex. When you see me objecting to someone, it is after a comprehensive assessment of the matter; one cannot simply judge the performance of an official from afar and condemn or endorse him. Of course, results must be seen in practice. What I constantly recommend to officials, whether in the executive or the judiciary, is that they show no favoritism or misplaced consideration when dealing with wrongdoing. I again emphasized this point to the several new ministers recently appointed. Judicial officials likewise should not be constrained by personal considerations in their work. If senior officials exercise responsibility without such hesitation or favoritism, there is hope that many apparent disorders can be corrected.

If you were an ordinary member of society like me, whom would you choose as your leader and as an authority whose instructions must be obeyed, and what qualities would you seek?

In accordance with the Constitution, I would seek someone I believed to be a faqih—that is, someone knowledgeable about religion and religious teachings—who was just, pious and courageous, unafraid to enter various fields of action and familiar with the country's affairs. I would consider such a person as leader. Of course he would also have to be elected according to law, since the Leader too is chosen legally. We cannot simply bring forward anyone and declare, 'This is our leader,' while someone else says, 'No, that is our leader.' There is a law, and the Leader is selected according to the principles of the Constitution and the existing regulations.

What do you consider the responsibilities of the Leader to be?

This follows on from the previous question. The Leader's duties and responsibilities are those specified in the Constitution. The Leader determines the system's general policies. In other words, all three branches of government must plan within the framework of those policies and adjust their executive policies accordingly. The system's general direction and structure must lie within the policies set by the Leader. That is the Leader's most important responsibility. The Constitution specifies other duties as well, and I recommend that you consult it to see them.

Why have you remained silent about the numerous problems in society that trouble and distress people, cause despair and drive away elites and those qualified to manage the country's affairs—including administrative chaos and hereditary positions, which are seen frequently?

If I encounter the things our dear brother or sister has written on this paper, I certainly will not remain silent. I do not know of any place where an office is hereditary. Some people may use their ties to a person or prominent figure to engage in certain activities or economic ventures—and these matters should be dealt with according to law. But I genuinely know of no hereditary office in society, where a father dies and his son inherits his position, or a brother dies and another brother inherits it. If such a thing exists, rest assured I will not remain silent.

The poor quality of educational and welfare services at Amirkabir University and the weak management of student welfare have caused dissatisfaction among the students.

I should say that our friends—the respected university president and professors present—spoke about precisely these matters more than anything else in our meeting before the student gathering. They too face certain constraints. We discussed expanding the university's facilities and issues surrounding the cafeteria. They raised these problems with me, although they should properly be taken to the Ministry of Science or the Management and Planning Organization. I will nevertheless follow up on them, and I have also instructed my office to do so. I have advised the responsible authorities and will continue to advise them. My point, however, is that the welfare and student problems you face, involving studies, the Internet, computers and other university needs, are exactly the problems these gentlemen themselves raised with me. I want you to know they are concerned about them, and God willing they will be resolved.

Given the doubts being spread and the hypocrisy of some officials, which tarnish the image of the Islamic system, what approaches do you recommend to avoid heedlessness or unwarranted extremism and to make decisions pleasing to God and based on Islam?

I generally advise young people, especially university and seminary students, to broaden their knowledge. Many deviations you observe arise from lack of awareness. Today's generation, particularly our youth, must know their country's history, especially the period since the Constitutional Revolution. Whatever your field of study, since you are among society's elite—and God willing will become its foremost members—you should understand the position your country occupied and occupies today. You should know, in particular, the history of the former regime. Today's generation does not properly know how the Islamic Revolution rescued this country from that regime's clutches. Those of us who experienced that regime with every fiber of our being know it well. This must be explained and conveyed. Works have, of course, been written on the subject. The former regime was corrupt, completely dependent on outsiders and utterly devoid of justice. The people counted for nothing in its calculations. To that regime, one American adviser or one Zionist tourist was worth far more than a vast number of Iranians. Its members were accustomed to living off others, consuming excessively, plundering national resources and exploiting the country's facilities illegitimately. The regime was founded on an illegitimate basis: the man who stood at its head, ruling for almost thirty-five years, had come to power solely because his father had ruled before him! Consider the faulty logic underlying one person's rule. All power and wealth were in his hands. If asked what justification he had for taking office, the answer was simply that his father had ruled there before him! He took power with the direct backing and desire of the British and ruled for thirty-five years. Naturally the country belonged to those who had put him in power or supported him. We have left such a regime behind. And why had his father taken power? Because there had been a British coup and that was what the British wanted. You must know the history of Reza Khan's coup in Esfand 1299 [1921], his subsequent accession to the throne in 1303 [1925], and then Mohammad Reza's succession. Television has broadcast worthwhile programs explaining these events, and books have been written about them as well.

You must become more knowledgeable about world affairs. I think that anyone—any young person or student—who knows from what bloodthirsty wolves this Revolution and system rescued the country, what hardships it endured over the past twenty-two years to reach the present point, and what hostilities it faced and continues to face, will understand precisely what he should do within this system. He will sense and recognize his duty. Iranian young people are perceptive, intelligent and politically aware, so no ambiguity remains. The remedy I suggest is reading books, studying more and drawing student gatherings into sound, genuine discussions rather than misleading ones. Of course, self-improvement, building one's inner character and illuminating one's heart are also extensive subjects deserving emphasis in their own right.

How do you assess yourself before God?

Before God I regard myself as a weak servant. This is not a matter of courtesy or empty modesty; it is the truth. I am a weak servant entrusted with a heavy responsibility, striving, God willing, to carry out what has been placed upon my shoulders.

At the beginning, the Islamic Revolution made certain claims. Now, after approximately twenty years, to what extent have those claims been fulfilled?

This is an important question. More than claims, the Revolution had ideals. It did not come to answer to the people of Iran as though it were separate from them; it was the people's own Revolution. The people made a revolution to realize their ideals: building a prosperous and free Iran; having an informed people enjoying social justice; and escaping dependency, scientific backwardness, and the despotism and coercion that ruled this country. You ask how far we have reached those goals. I say their realization is gradual; it requires struggle, effort and step-by-step progress. The Islamic system is not prefabricated like a prefabricated house. It must be built brick by brick and stone by stone. Problems naturally arise during the work. The concepts I mentioned—social justice, freedom, awareness and spirituality, which form the system's foundations—are not static or rigid. Their concrete applications may change with progress and the demands of the times. During this arduous work it is only natural for problems to emerge, since one must continually design and construct and ensure that no part of the building is put up in the wrong direction. There may be disagreements, shortages of materials or labor, and the enemy may bombard the structure with catapults and destroy a corner of it. A builder or laborer may do something incorrectly in one part, requiring repairs. Sometimes the architects and builders themselves may have weaknesses or be lazy. It is not always true that weaknesses are imposed by others. Thus there are many difficulties on this path: shortages of materials, companions who abandon the journey halfway, and greedy, power-seeking people are among them. We must build this system and advance little by little, step by step.

If you ask how much progress we have made, however, I shall say we have progressed considerably. Anyone familiar with this country's past can see it. Once the people did not count; today the people are at the center of decision-making. Spirituality was under fierce assault, with attempts to eliminate it; today its lamp burns brightly among the people. In the past young people were deliberately led into corruption. You may have heard that the country's rulers and their families were among the main partners in drug-trafficking networks. They first brought heroin to this country and distributed it. With their own hands they spread corruption, addiction and misery. Today the system stands against these problems with all its strength and great effort, and the whole world acknowledges its work; but in those days appearances and publicity stunts were the officials' priority. Villages, rural roads, village electrification and needs in distant towns were utterly neglected. They claimed they wanted to nurture elites, yet over fifty years they had produced a country with only about 150,000 university students. I was exiled to Sistan and Baluchestan and knew the figures precisely then, though I cannot remember them exactly now. I think throughout that province, with a population of about six or seven hundred thousand at the time, there were only three university graduates, and perhaps twenty people with secondary-school diplomas. Today every city in the country has a university; many cities have several, with numerous students, a variety of subjects and extensive scientific advances.

I have said many times that the Americans sold us fighter aircraft and other equipment, yet would not allow us to repair them. Indeed, the story of those sales is extraordinary. At that time there was a joint fund between Iran and America. I discovered it early in the Revolution, when I went to work at the Ministry of Defense, and later followed it up in Parliament. Unfortunately the Americans have still not answered to this day! They had a fund known by the initials FMS into which the Iranian government paid money, but the Americans decided the prices, the types of goods and withdrawals. When the Revolution triumphed, billions of dollars remained in that fund; the Americans have still not accounted for it or returned the money to the Iranian people. When an aircraft arrived in Iran it eventually needed maintenance. Do you suppose there were workshops and repair facilities here? Not at all. If a component malfunctioned and was removed from the aircraft—and there were large assemblies made of dozens of parts—they would not permit it to be opened or repaired here. They flew it to America, exchanged it for a new component and brought it back to Iran. That was how they treated this nation. Today Iran manufactures aircraft of the same kind. The Tondar aircraft made by our own personnel flew. The situation is simply incomparable with that era.

We have therefore made considerable progress. But if you ask whether I am satisfied with this much, the answer is absolutely not. We still have a long way to go. We have not yet reached the social justice Islam requires of us, on which Islam is very demanding, nor the level of freedom the Iranian nation deserves. There is work ahead of us. This is a long road. I repeatedly tell young people to prepare themselves for precisely this reason: you must travel it. Along every kilometer of this road stands a sign saying 'No stopping.' We must not stop. The soldiers of social justice must be tireless. Those moving along long paths toward great ideals must not feel exhausted. That is how a nation reaches dignity, leadership and its ideals. No nation gains greatness and happiness through laziness. The greatest disaster would be for a people to say, 'Since we failed to meet all our goals, let's abandon them.' No; the goals must be pursued.

Let me tell you that the Iranian nation's resources—material and human—are exceptional. Early in the Revolution I heard from trustworthy friends who had studied abroad that among students at the world's foremost scientific institutions, Iranians always stood out for their intelligence. Unfortunately many of them, for reasons prevailing at the time, did not follow their studies or careers through to the end. Beyond these immense human and material assets, we possess the immense asset of the Islamic Revolution, which awakened us, restored our self-awareness, acquainted us with human values, and made us conscious of our country's important political and geographic place in the world. We know that ours is a great country and should receive its rightful share of global importance through scientific development and political and economic progress. This is our capital.

Without exaggeration, our system is today the world's most popular system, in the sense of having the closest connection between people and officials. Nowhere else is that relationship like ours. In no other country is there the sincerity and connection of this meeting between you and me, or similar meetings with other officials. The celebrated democracies of the world are in reality governments of cartels, trusts and large corporations, one glimpse of which appeared in America's recent elections. They are the ones exercising power. The people in fact have no say, although they may imagine themselves to be participating. We possess immense assets of this sort.

Many people, however, try to belittle these assets in your eyes and mine. They wish to steal them from us. A common way of wresting something valuable from its owner, employed by brokers and unscrupulous people everywhere, is to disparage it repeatedly, saying that it has no worth and should be discarded. They say this because you and I have not handed them the immense capital we possess. My advice to you young people, therefore, is to work and strive.

When I was your age, during the struggle and the Revolution, I worked day and night. I thank God that my youth passed in constant effort. Even now, when I am over sixty and counted among the elderly, I thank God that I still claim no rest or leisure for myself. I am continually occupied, and as long as I live and am able, I shall continue working in this way. My advice to everyone is to keep active and work.

How do you see the future of this Revolution and system?

What I have said makes the answer clear. I see a very bright future. I regard the presence of this great multitude of young people in our country as a blessing and something extremely valuable. Our officials are good officials too. This does not mean they are free of defects—of course there are shortcomings here and there—but fortunately, on the whole, good people are in office today, and so the future is good.

In your view, how should we deal with senior officials who are attached to worldly interests?

You should deal with them one way, I another, and the judiciary yet another. In my view, you should advise them as far as you can: 'Offering sincere counsel to the leaders of Muslims.' Whoever you feel is worldly-minded, advise them in whatever way you can, and know that advice does have an effect.

One much-discussed problem these days, to which the real intended audience pays little attention in practice, is the brain drain. I do not know how to prevent talented young people who have studied with such effort from emigrating. For example, I myself studied at a leading university—Amirkabir—in a demanding subject at master's level, yet despite all my academic effort I cannot find suitable work. The problem is not merely the absence of personal connections; there simply are no suitable jobs. Most companies and factories settle for outdated technologies, and the officials supposed to manage affairs are busy with factionalism and pursuing power. The people's elected president is under such pressure that everyone can see it, and no one dares speak for fear of being sent to prison. For whom are we to work and strive? For those who wear the sacred robe of the clergy but pursue worldly ambitions? It seems, considering the many Quranic verses about migration, that our duty in order to remain morally sound is to leave!

First, corruption is not confined to clerics or non-clerics. When clerics become corrupt, the damage their corruption causes is greater. I agree with our respected friend that, God forbid, if clerics turn toward corruption, the harm they cause is greater than that caused by others.

As for the statement that companies and factories settle for outdated technology, in many places this is indeed true. The remedy is what I told you the other day and what I have repeatedly told government officials. This must be done and will be done: the country's scientific institutions must be connected with its industrial sector. That way scientific institutions will be put into motion, knowledge will be joined with practice, and the country's industrial organizations will evolve and be transformed. But it has not yet happened. I advised both the previous president in the former administration and the current president emphatically about this. I told them that linking the country's scientific and industrial sectors is not a task for a ministry, whether the Ministry of Industries or the Ministry of Science. It is a task for the presidency itself: an office should be established in the presidential institution solely to connect universities with industrial organizations at the coordinating and policy level, not through direct field execution. A person responsible was also designated, but apparently it has not yet been implemented. It certainly will and must happen. That is the remedy.

The country today has many industrial capabilities. I am sure our friend who submitted this question does not know about many of its industrial centers. Very good and advanced work is being carried out. If, for example, you visit industrial exhibitions once a year, you will see it for yourself. It is genuinely heartening and sometimes astonishing. I do not want to compare Iran with a European country that has led industry for two hundred years. We entered this field only twenty years ago, because before the Revolution such work had no meaning. The country's most important factory then was Iran Khodro, a mere assembly plant. There was none of this production, construction and innovation. We started only twenty years ago, eight of which were consumed by war. In reality we have been active in the field for ten or twelve years, and so expectations should not be exaggerated. I do not seek to compare us with those countries, but we have advanced quickly and, God willing, will continue. If what I told the two respected presidents of the former and current administrations had been implemented earlier, it would certainly have produced better results. I have now become personally involved too. Only yesterday, when we were undertaking necessary work with a group of colleagues, I again emphasized this issue.

As for the claim that we have no choice but to leave to remain morally sound, I do not accept it. What does remaining sound mean? Do you imagine that migrants from other countries receive such consideration abroad? Do you think every country will respect your worth, dignity and honor as a young Iranian? Sit down and listen to the experiences and grievances of people who have gone abroad. For a conscientious person it is far more satisfying and joyful to remain at home, benefit one's family, work hard and apply all one's determination, even with a somewhat lower standard of living, than to go to another country and turn one's back on homeland, family and the soil that nurtured one's abilities and education—including Amirkabir University, to which you owe a debt—and work in a stranger's land under others' condescension and scowls merely for a little more money. Is that migration in the Islamic sense? Absolutely not. This is not Islamic migration; it is 'returning to ignorance after emigration.' It is fleeing the field of work, responsibility and duty for a place where one's personal life might be a little better. I do not agree with it at all. Of course, I also said that I understand the expectations of our talented young people. They are entitled to expect opportunities, and officials must work for them; there is no doubt about that. But if officials have fallen short, that does not justify young people inventing excuses for themselves. If someone goes abroad to acquire further knowledge or do research and then returns, that is not fleeing and is perfectly acceptable. But packing one's bags, turning one's back and saying 'Goodbye, I'm leaving'—no, I do not accept that.

When the Imam, may God's mercy be upon him, passed through a place in Najaf, people could set their watches by his arrival. But it was not right for us to wait an hour to see our Leader!

I certainly do not claim the degree of punctuality you describe here. However, I attach great importance to keeping the appointments I make, especially with gatherings; I count the minutes. That day I arrived on time, perhaps two or three minutes before the meeting began, and our appointment was at ten-thirty. If you waited an hour, I am not responsible for that.

Since this year is the Year of Imam Ali, peace be upon him, his example ought to be implemented in every sphere. In this connection I want to ask: when Imam Ali appeared in court against a Jewish man during his rule and claimed no privileges for himself, what place is there for the Special Court for the Clergy in a country that claims to follow him?

The very existence of the Special Court for the Clergy is no privilege for clerics. You should know that some of its strongest critics are themselves clerics; thus it is not a privilege. It was first established by the Imam to apply greater scrutiny and strictness to clerics. The reason for setting it up was that it had always been assumed that clerics might naturally receive special treatment in an ordinary court. A respected cleric might be accused of wrongdoing, yet be treated differently from an ordinary person. With a Special Court for the Clergy, that distinction no longer exists. The Special Court is a court like any other and is no different from a branch of the Tehran judiciary. It is entirely wrong to imagine that clerics enjoy a special advantage there; on the contrary, it imposes greater strictness upon them. As a cleric myself, and someone very sensitive to corruption among clerics, I tell you that the court is beneficial rather than harmful. Of course, some people stir up political controversies when a cleric associated with a particular political tendency is summoned there and create an uproar against the court. But the court gives no privilege to clerics whatsoever and is a good, useful institution. The Imam established it and I was among those who approved of it. He consulted certain people, including me, and I said it was a very good idea. I still believe the same: it is good and does not constitute a privilege.

Although you said the events at the university dormitory wounded your heart, why did you remain silent when those responsible for attacking the dormitory were acquitted? Was your silence not a sign that you were satisfied?

The university dormitory incident truly wounded my heart. This was neither a joke nor a mere polite expression. But you know that what happened in the university dormitory was a highly complex affair with multiple elements. It was not simply a matter of four people going into the dormitory and committing an act. The judiciary investigated the case. Everyone must accept the judiciary's judgment. Whether or not I am satisfied with the ruling, the worst thing I could do would be to say, 'I do not accept the verdict.' That is neither proper nor acceptable. What court anywhere in the world produces a verdict that satisfies everyone involved? Look at any trial: inevitably one side is satisfied and the other is not. This court and others are run by judges whom, for the most part, I do not know personally; I have seen them on television and heard their names. But the judiciary trusts them. They have been selected and vetted, are just, and comply with the judiciary's rules and standards. There are also laws and mechanisms that hold any judge to account if he acts unlawfully. A trial has therefore taken place and a verdict has been issued. We must accept the court's ruling. If the court says that a particular person is not guilty of the incident, then that person is not guilty. Neither you nor I were there to know whether that individual was guilty. The court must determine the outcome.

As a general principle, not only in this particular case but in all cases, I believe that undermining a country's judiciary is the starting point of corruption in that country. The judiciary must therefore not be discredited. This does not mean it always acts correctly, or that all its members or all its actions are faultless. Certainly there are violations within it. Recently the judiciary brought the head of a court to trial, and he is now in prison. Thus it does take action. If that person had belonged to a political faction, there would undoubtedly have been an international uproar about it; but because he is not affiliated, there is no great noise! The judiciary deals decisively with corruption within its own ranks. Although I do not claim it is flawless or free of problems or that every member is good, everyone must recognize the institution of the judiciary, respect it and refrain from discrediting it. If the judiciary is undermined, every criminal can use some pretext to escape investigation and trial, and it becomes impossible to prosecute anyone. Therefore everyone must submit to court judgments.

In your opinion, what caused the unsuccessful performance of cultural institutions over the past twenty years?

It would be wrong to say that the cultural institutions' performance has been entirely unsuccessful. They have achieved a great deal as well. People generally see the empty half of the glass and pay little attention to the full half. Our cultural institutions have also had successes. Where they have failed, several factors were responsible, including insufficient effort and lack of initiative. These relate to management. Weak managers generally do too little, show too little initiative and fail to select capable people, or surrender to waves of Western culture. Do not underestimate this. Seven or eight years ago I raised the issue of cultural assault, but many reacted harshly and asked what such an assault could mean, although it is a very significant, sensitive and dangerous reality. Westerners seek to impose their cultural norms on various countries. If a manager becomes passive and submissive toward them, the very problems we have seen arise. Managerial surrender is one of the most important, effective and harmful factors leading cultural institutions astray. When a cultural institution deviates, the consequences become apparent in society. An institution that ought to make films, produce books and use every cultural instrument to promote people's intellectual, cultural and practical development naturally draws my criticism when I see it neglecting those duties. This should not be interpreted as a political alignment; it is exactly the issue our brother or sister has raised here.

Do you not think changes in the leadership of institutions and the media are necessary for creativity and new approaches?

Yes. Whenever we perceive weak management in an institution and can identify a better, more capable person to replace the manager, such a replacement would undoubtedly have a significant effect. I have always said the same thing to the country's officials, whether ministers or those above them.

Do you think Friday prayer has become a platform for officials to defend their own performance?

No, I do not believe that. Who comes to Friday prayer and defends his own record? Perhaps one or two officials sometimes lead Tehran Friday prayers, but the others are not officials. Certainly some may come and speak about services they have performed, whether Friday prayer leaders or speakers preceding the sermons. But there is no harm in an official coming to explain his record to the people. After all, one of the duties of the Friday prayer platform is to keep the audience informed about the country's circumstances.

How, in your opinion, can our motivation to attend Friday prayers be strengthened?

I would like young people to attend because I believe Friday prayer is beneficial. Spending an hour on it during the week is not much time. It is worship, remembrance of God and an opportunity to hear worthwhile remarks. But you should analyze everything you hear from me or anyone else—not only Friday sermons—in the workshop of your own mind. Say to yourself: this part was right and that part was wrong. There is nothing wrong with that. If you and other listeners follow this advice, you can benefit from the useful parts of a speaker's words without being harmed by the harmful parts. In my view, do not make this a pretext or excuse for staying away from Friday prayer.

How is the conduct of the Guardian Jurist supervised? At present the Assembly of Experts meets twice a year and mostly confines itself to issuing statements. Can it truly supervise the Guardian Jurist through this procedure?

The Assembly of Experts has an investigative committee responsible for examining the Leader's actions. Its work is not performed only once a year; it carries on its duties, while the Leader's work is visible to everyone. Fortunately the leadership's organization and activities are not secret, because the Leader's duties and actions are defined. The committee comes, investigates and asks questions. Behind the committee stands the Assembly of Experts, to which it reports. In the one or two days of its meetings, the members of the Assembly hold extensive discussions. They do not merely issue a statement. The statement is what appears in the media, but numerous issues are discussed and a variety of opinions expressed. Thus they do their work. Two meetings per year are not few for such a weighty institution. Previously the Assembly met once annually; in recent years it has convened twice. Behind the Assembly of Experts stand the people.

Supervision must also be serious and free of personal embarrassment or hesitation. This is my own view, and I have said so repeatedly to members of the Assembly and others. I welcome oversight and strongly object to any attempt to evade it, whoever may do so. The more closely I myself am supervised, the happier I am. I do not feel that oversight imposes any burden on me. I therefore welcome its exercise. If anyone has conducted supervision and knows something, the proper course is to inform the Assembly of Experts; its members will certainly make use of it.

I would like to know briefly your opinion of 'nihilism' in the contemporary world and the origins of this psychological tendency and inclination.

Nihilism means belief in meaninglessness, and it is a reprehensible concept. This doctrine is among the products and fruits of material life in the West: a lack and poverty of spirituality lead young people in particular toward nihilism. It is nothing new; I remember the phenomenon from my own youth. Back then there was a group called the Beatles, who wore their hair in a distinctive style and played music. Recently I saw their photographs in a foreign magazine; they have grown old. Some people in countries captivated by and submissive to the West—I do not like to call them 'Third World' or 'backward' countries, since these terms are inappropriate—would imitate them. At our previous gathering I said that some people have translated tastes and ways of thinking. People like that imitate whatever the West does. When the Beatles appeared in a European country during my youth, we immediately saw young people here styling their hair the same way! That is a bad thing. Its origin lies in Western material life and the lack of spirituality. If we want to prevent nihilism in our society, the way is to reinforce spirituality and motivation. Fortunately these qualities exist in our society today, and I strongly urge you never to let your intense motivation, zeal, enthusiasm and attachment to ideals diminish in the slightest.

For some time you have repeatedly mentioned poverty, corruption and discrimination in your speeches and called for their elimination. My question is whether these problems have existed only in the past three and a half years and the people enjoyed prosperity before that. If not, why did you not raise them during the Reconstruction period?

Our friend must surely be very young. Had this person followed my statements over the years, he would have seen that I have always emphasized these issues. In this very place where I am now sitting, at the ceremony confirming the former respected president's second term, I warned about the emergence of a new social class and made very important remarks on these questions. Such warnings and reminders have always featured in my statements. It is simply not true that I raised poverty, corruption and discrimination only in recent years. By emphasizing their elimination now, I wished to clarify a fundamental point. The question of reform in the country—a very good thing, for continual reform is both attractive and necessary in every country—had become a political instrument in the hands of some who recognize neither the system, nor Islam, nor the Constitution, nor this government, the president, the leadership, ministers or anyone else. In short, they reject the entire system. Without defining the word 'reform,' they began exploiting it politically. I therefore said that reform, which is necessary and which everyone, including all three branches, must pursue, consists in the first instance of these three things. In effect I offered a clear definition of reform, one they could not deny, because who would claim that eliminating poverty, discrimination and corruption is unnecessary or does not count as reform? Yet they do not work for reforms of that kind. Instead they constantly stir up political storms in the country over vague, undefined demands, drag people in different directions and target universities. Is that right? I wanted to give direction to the efforts some were making, and fortunately that happened. Both before and after raising the issue publicly, I summoned the heads of the three branches, spoke with them and received their commitment to plan. They did plan and are now undertaking measures. Thus in the previous government too, I called upon officials to work particularly against corruption, discrimination and poverty. In response, they drew up a poverty-reduction bill. It could not be completed during that government's term; afterward the current government revised and organized the same bill, and some stages have already moved forward. The employment initiative you have heard about in recent days follows from it, since employment is the most important issue.

Do you not think the performance of clerical officials in government has caused poverty?

If the suggestion is that clerics holding positions of authority have caused poverty, no, that is wrong. None of the sectors directly responsible for these matters is headed by a cleric. Which ministers of economy and finance, commerce, agriculture, industries, labor or cooperatives have been clerics over these years? As for the clerics who have served as president, both the present and former presidents were elected by the people. The clergy as such have no role in economic work or planning for which poverty could be attributed to them. The causes lie elsewhere. Of course there are many inherited causes of poverty in society. Useful, organized effort and the necessary attention have been influenced by other currents. During Reconstruction, developing the country became the principal priority. Yet reconstruction is not the same as immediately eliminating poverty. Reconstruction means creating new opportunities and economic growth, while poverty may persist in parts of society. If reconstruction continues, it will gradually remove poverty, but building the economy does not mean eliminating poverty at the very first stages. Development must continue; as it does, poverty will gradually diminish.

Do you have a plan to combat poverty and corruption?

Although preparing detailed plans for these matters is not the Leader's responsibility, yes, I do have plans. If I were personally implementing them, I have reliable and acceptable approaches that I have shared with officials, and, wherever necessary and possible, I have guided both the former and current governments toward the directions I consider appropriate. Fortunately much of the work accomplished has arisen from such intellectual assistance. This is not something the governments disagree with; they acknowledge it and have repeatedly said so. So yes, I have plans, but planning is the responsibility of governments. Each government must develop and implement programs within its own executive policies. Our role is to assist, which, God willing, we shall continue to do, as we have done until now.

What do you think of Parliament's recent resolution preventing the police from entering universities?

I do not express an opinion on parliamentary resolutions of this kind, because taking a position on either side may impose constraints upon a group. I support any resolution once it has become law.

Polytechnic University was once among the country's leading institutions in industry and science, but recently the university's deteriorating conditions—research facilities, services, Internet access, and so forth—have made scientific progress difficult for students.

I addressed this at the beginning of my remarks. The university officials raised exactly these issues with me, and they share your concerns. I hope, God willing, they will gradually resolve them. I do, however, have one complaint about our friend who wrote this letter. You know 'Polytechnic' is a foreign word. What advantage does it have that would justify preferring it to 'Amirkabir University of Technology'? Please call it 'Amirkabir University' from now on.

In your remarks about the chain murders you spoke of foreign involvement, but the case investigation made no reference to this aspect and indeed seemed to suggest the exact opposite. Please explain.

I expressed that same view at the outset, when I spoke about this controversial and truly damaging issue, and I still believe nothing different. I would rather not revive the debate, because it caused the country great harm. An incident had occurred and the intelligence and judicial authorities should have resolved it. Instead, taking it before public opinion, generating artificial excitement, and issuing unrealistic and sometimes wholly false statements from every side created an extremely harmful atmosphere. I am therefore not at all pleased at the prospect of reopening these arguments. Fortunately the trial has ended and the debate subsided, but since the question has been asked I will answer.

I still believe what I said before. Consider the various aspects of this matter. One is the criminal aspect: several people connected with a government organization went out and murdered a number of individuals. This was a crime and had to be dealt with as such. The court convened for the case expressly said it would examine only the criminal aspect, not other dimensions; its jurisdiction extended only that far, and it carried out that examination. On the other hand, when we look at the killers, we see that they had no personal animosity, grudge or conflict of interests with the victims that would explain the killings. Nor were those individuals so politically harmful or dangerous to the country that we could suppose the killers acted to defend the system. That was not the case. I said in a Friday sermon that one victim had been my old friend during the years of struggle, a colleague after the Islamic Revolution, and in recent years a harmless opponent. He was an adversary whose opposition truly caused the system very little harm. It therefore makes no sense to suppose that loyalty to the system motivated these people to kill someone who posed no danger to it. Moreover, the burden of the crime upon the system was enormous, creating insecurity and distrust. Worst of all, the country's intelligence organization was attacked and discredited. What would an ordinary mind naturally infer under these circumstances, even without any additional evidence? Would it not infer that some hand wished to damage the intelligence service, disgrace the system, create insecurity and spread an accusation throughout the world that the Islamic Republic represses its opponents? Any ordinary person can grasp this. I also had considerable circumstantial evidence; it was not merely this inference. Subsequent confessions confirmed it as well. If a thorough security investigation and precise trial were undertaken, do not be surprised if illuminating evidence and indications emerged and became public. But the court that was established examined only the criminal aspect of the matter.

* * *

Many questions remain unanswered because there were so many, and more were brought later. It is now noon and the call to prayer has been given, so I apologize that there is no time left for the other questions. May God grant all of you success and assistance, and may your pure hearts and radiant souls grow day by day upon God's straight path. God willing, may you create a very good and bright future for your country, your beloved home Iran, and coming generations, and bring honor to Islam, for you are the children of Islam.

Peace be upon you, and the mercy and blessings of God.
 
Pursuit of Ideals Reformism Accountability of Officials Cultural Assault Understanding the Enemy Social Justice Justice and Progress Economic Corruption Shaping Public Discourse Rule of Law Achievements of the Islamic Revolution Scientific Endeavor Justice-Seeking Movement National Identity University–Industry Cooperation Iran’s Scientific Movement Cultural Endeavor Scientific Progress in Iran Sense of Responsibility Scientific Independence Freedom of the Press Political Analytical Ability Combating Privilege and Rent-Seeking