1377/05/03
Remarks at a Meeting with Members of the Congress Commemorating the Late Haj Molla Ali Akhund of Hamadan
In the name of God, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.
Thank you very much for taking the trouble to come here and thereby allowing me, to this extent, to share in the blessing and reward of honoring the late Akhund Molla Ali (may God be pleased with him). Thank you sincerely. The undertaking itself is very important.
I did not have the opportunity to meet the late Akhund, but I knew of him, as everyone did. In his lifetime, during the years I was in Mashhad, no one could have been unaware of him; he was among the country’s leading religious scholars. I heard about his scholarly qualities from those who had met him, including some friends and students of his.
First, he was a very strong and accomplished jurist and scholar of legal theory, and among the outstanding students of the late Haj Sheikh. Apparently, he went to Qom around the lunar year 1340, at about the time Haj Sheikh arrived there, and studied under him for several years. I believe he moved to Hamadan and settled there while Haj Sheikh was still alive. In short, he was a highly learned scholar of jurisprudence, its principles, and the evaluation of hadith transmitters.
One thing I heard repeatedly from different people was that he was also an expert in the science of hadith transmitters. It is a great distinction for a jurist to form his own scholarly judgments in that field rather than simply follow others. He was also deeply familiar with Qur’anic exegesis and the traditions.
In short, he was a jurist, a scholar of legal theory and narrators, an exegete, a traditionist and a morally cultivated scholar. In truth, we had very few people of this kind in the country, particularly at such an elevated level. His standing was therefore very high. He was also devoted to spiritual discipline and ethics, and his students and associates benefited from his spirituality.
What attracted my attention to the late Akhund’s character, beyond these spiritual merits, was that a highly accomplished mujtahid like Akhund Molla Ali would undoubtedly have been at the head, or among the leading figures, of any seminary he joined. He would certainly not have been in a subordinate position. Had he come to Qom in the time of Ayatollah Golpayegani and Ayatollah Damad, those well-known students of Haj Sheikh, he would hardly have remained in anyone’s shadow, especially with his strong ability to establish and demonstrate his scholarly standing. He was strong both in the substance of his knowledge and in demonstrating it.
Yet this man went to Hamadan and settled there. To me, it was striking and significant for a religious authority to act in this way. I was living in Mashhad at the time. The late Ayatollah Milani was a senior religious authority there, but Mashhad was itself one of the major cities of the Islamic world, a large city with a major seminary; one could not praise a scholar simply for residing in Mashhad. Yet two figures always attracted my attention: Akhund and the late Aqa Sheikh Mohammad. Sheikh Mohammad was likewise a first-rate scholar who settled in Borujerd. Akhund was a first-rate scholar who settled in Hamadan. In my view, this was very important and a great undertaking.
The late Ayatollah Khansari belonged to a somewhat earlier generation than Akhund, but it was not clear that he surpassed Akhund in scholarship or mastery. To put oneself aside like that, to subdue the ego and forgo leadership, religious authority and the like! I even heard that Akhund had not published a practical legal manual, though the people of Hamadan followed him in religious matters. Mr. Jalali of Hamadan sometimes spoke about Akhund. He said that when a difficulty arose between the late Ayatollah Borujerdi and Akhund, the people of Hamadan sent a message to Borujerdi, great as he was: “You introduced Akhund to us. If you do not recognize him, we do not recognize you either!” Consider how devoted people were to such a scholar, yet he did not issue a manual of religious rulings. He preached from the pulpit but did not recite the mourning narrative. These are significant things.
I would like to draw a lesson from this: I wish we would study the practical example of great figures such as Akhund, so that it could continue today, with outstanding scholars going to live in different cities. Let the pillars of learning be present throughout the country. Let there be genuine seminaries in every city that train mujtahids, so people everywhere can rely on a firm support like Akhund Molla Ali. There may not be many people like him now, but it is very valuable for such personalities to reside in the cities of this country.
May God elevate his rank. Honoring him is undoubtedly honoring learning, piety, spirituality and sincerity; it is a great and valuable task. I thank you in turn for undertaking it. He surely left scholarly works; it is unlikely that someone of such expertise never put pen to paper. These works must be sought out and found, perhaps in marginal notes in books. I believe this could itself be a research project: to search for and collect his scholarly writings. After all, even if a scholar of his caliber delivered sermons, those sermons ought to be written down and studied. Even if such a man related a story or recounted history and memories, people could learn from it. In any case, finding and publishing any scholarly work by him would certainly be appropriate. I consider it useful and necessary.
Peace be upon you and God’s mercy and blessings.