→ Back to search
1377/02/22 (Solar Hijri) 1998-05-12 (Gregorian)

1377/02/22- Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session at the University of Tehran

1377/02/22

Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session at the University of Tehran

بسم‌اللَّه‌الرحمن‌الرحیم‌

Write down whatever points occur to you, and afterward I shall say what I think needs to be said. But I would like the dear students to ask questions and for me to answer them. Surely at least some of what is said will be useful, if not all of it. Nor will it waste my time: I have set aside today for precisely this. I postponed all my other work until this afternoon so I could be here with you. Of course, there will be many questions, and they will probably keep coming; I may be able to answer only some, because there will not be enough time for all of them. Perhaps it would be better to take the questions away and have colleagues categorize them, so that answers can later be prepared and returned to you. I cannot promise definitively, but I shall try. It would be very good if that could be done.

Some people object to the presence of the Basij or Student Basij at universities on grounds such as its allegedly military character, and have imposed restrictions. What is your view?

The Basij is not necessarily a military organization; indeed, it is not inherently military. Basij means the people. I myself could belong to the Basij without being a soldier. Basij members exist in universities, factories, religious seminaries, offices—everywhere. The Basij is not a military organization. There is absolutely nothing wrong with students belonging to it; on the contrary, it is undoubtedly a virtue. There would be nothing wrong if everyone joined.

Although all members of the Student Basij are students who registered voluntarily and enthusiastically, university officials treat this group harshly.

No, I do not believe it is appropriate to impose harsh restrictions on the Basij. Of course, I do not know the details; I must later ask the university president whether this is actually happening. Nobody in this country is hostile to the Basij. The Basij has served the country so much that no one can question its usefulness—or, indeed, its necessity. It is a legacy of the Imam.

What is your opinion of the poisoned atmosphere of the country's press?

Well, the press is the press! Some publications are good, others better; some bad, others worse. Each has its own readership. I believe the way to deal with bad publications is to develop good ones. If the country's media landscape is filled appropriately with useful publications, the bad ones—what you call bad, though what criterion determines badness is itself another question—will have little room to operate.

After the presidential election and the people's magnificent turnout at the ballot boxes, some individuals and officials use various expressions to create divisions and exploit the respected, popular president for their own interests.

The president is not someone who can readily be exploited. He is an outstanding, learned and informed figure. He has chosen the right course and is following it. Individuals may say things for themselves, but I do not believe anyone can exploit the president, God willing.

The greatest problem of our universities is an atmosphere of stagnation and rigid traditionalism in the sphere of knowledge and authentic Islamic culture. How can this atmosphere be eliminated?

That is a very important point worthy of attention. I doubt that it is our single greatest problem, but rigidity and intellectual stagnation are undoubtedly problematic wherever they occur. The way to remove them is for you students to improve the quality of your knowledge and understanding as much as possible. When any one of you is knowledgeable, cultured, wise, enlightened and educated, you can spread those qualities in practice—the exact opposite of an atmosphere of rigidity. The struggle against stagnation must be cultural, not a struggle with swords, because stagnation belongs to the realm of culture. Rigid traditionalism is itself a kind of culture, though a closed one, and must be confronted through cultural means. I believe students can play an effective part.

If possible, please discuss and examine the problems faced by the families of martyrs, particularly students from those families. We hope you will agree to this request.

I do not know whether the suggestion is that I speak to those students myself or appoint someone to do so. In either case, we can examine the problem. Although we have not brought our office equipment here, one of you gentlemen should write this down so I can ask my office to follow up afterward. Set this paper aside for later attention.

How can we clearly learn your authentic line of thought concerning guardianship and current everyday issues so that others cannot misrepresent your views?

What I say in my speeches is the essence of my views. My most fundamental opinions are precisely those you hear in my addresses. I hold no view on the country's current affairs, Islam and Muslims, or social matters that I tell someone privately but cannot state openly. My opinions are clear and transparent; you hear them in Friday sermons and my addresses to different groups.

Does our beloved Quran not say that human beings were created free and that the greatest freedom is the freedom to read and write? Why, then, has this right been taken from us in the Islamic Republic?

I do not know who has taken it away! Identify whoever has done so, and I shall go and reclaim your right for you! The truth is that you young people did not experience Iran before the revolution, nor have you seen many other countries. Fortunately, freedom of thought and of expressing thought is exceptionally extensive in Iran today. I do not mean that Islam grants this freedom without any conditions; it does not. There are restrictions in this area, and our laws provide for them. Perhaps the resulting framework accords with the Quranic teachings you mention. But freedom does exist today and that is very good. This very meeting, in which you speak, I read your words and we sit together, is also a rarity in the world. I am pleased if respect for human dignity and identity in our country is such that it raises people's expectations; there is nothing wrong with that. But look at other countries comparable to ours, with similar historical experiences, and compare their freedoms: fortunately you will find no equivalent to Iran in this respect.

What plans have you made concerning marriage among university students?

This is an important question, and I do not take it lightly at all. I think the relevant officials must pay attention to it. We have repeatedly made recommendations to government officials both about young people's marriage and its practical requirements, including housing, a matter I have been raising with the Ministry of Housing for a long time. They have undertaken some measures, including constructing temporary rental housing for newly married couples. We hope the necessary preparations are made and the problem of marriage can be resolved. On this matter, you are indeed right.

What responsibilities do newly recruited academic faculty members have in helping to make universities Islamic?

Making universities Islamic is on the agenda of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution. It has plans, has undertaken activities, and has broken the issue down into its various aspects. In this respect I see no difference between newly recruited and longstanding faculty. In any case, I have never interfered in the methods used. University authorities and the distinguished members of the Supreme Council must decide on the methods. I proposed the idea, demanded action from them, and will continue to demand it. If universities have become Islamic, let it be clear what I asked for and meant. I do not believe a single person in the universities fails to recognize the need for it or its value and benefits. Everyone therefore has a duty to help. I do feel, however, that the meaning of making universities Islamic has not always been correctly understood. Some have understood it in a very narrow and weak sense. What I mean is something far more elevated.

Given the very limited resources available for graduate study, is scientific advancement to the necessary level possible?

I do not know the exact state of resources in universities, but I know the government has decided to expand students' educational and research facilities. Budget shortages and financial difficulties may temporarily produce deficiencies at some universities, but the government's firm intention is to remedy them.

Do you think scientific progress is faster in Iran or in America?

That is a very strange question. Americans have worked in science for many years. While they were freely training scientists and making progress with their own national resources and resources plundered from other countries, our nation was under a regime whose repression, dependence, political corruption and moral corruption did not even allow Iranian scientists to think! Do you expect us under those circumstances to have kept pace with America? That is an excessive expectation.

I may have said this before. When fighter jets were bought from America under the previous regime, if a component malfunctioned—even when the larger component itself contained dozens of smaller parts—the Americans would not allow our air-force technicians to open it, identify the faulty small part and replace it! The entire assembly, sometimes made of dozens or hundreds of pieces, had to be put aboard a plane and sent to America to be replaced and returned. That is how they behaved. Our country lacked adequate student numbers, educational quality, opportunities for work, and a spirit of intellectual development, research, teaching and investigation. How could you expect Iran to advance under those conditions?

We began only nineteen years ago. Those nineteen years included the problems at the beginning of the revolution, the events at this university, armed groups, and the war. I have many memories of this very mosque—the University of Tehran mosque—from before and after the revolution. Let me tell you one. In 1979 I used to come here one day a week, perhaps Sunday or Monday, to perform the noon prayer. Students would gather; I answered questions and spoke to them. That same year, the University of Tehran had become a stronghold of armed factions operating under various names. Armed with G3 rifles and Kalashnikovs, they attacked people outside the university and Muslim students from inside the campus! One day, when serious clashes were raging, I came at noon as usual. Some students approached me as I entered and said it was dangerous and I should not come. I said I would not cancel my program. I went in. The campus was almost deserted, with only an occasional person in sight because it was so dangerous. Students came to the mosque along our route. Perhaps fewer than ten people gathered there; everyone else had fled. I think we prayed and left—in truth we were somewhat frightened ourselves. Soon afterward universities were closed for a period, perhaps about a year throughout the country. Think what such periods meant during those nineteen years: clashes, lost study time, and demonstrations and strikes imposed on universities almost daily. What are their effects? If students are prevented from studying, can scientific flourishing suddenly appear like lightning? Then the imposed war and its problems came. Universities had reopened and classes were held, but the country was at war. If we sift these nineteen years, fewer than ten years of effective work remain. In reality, only after the war could we attend properly to universities.

Therefore, our pace of scientific progress over ten years cannot equal America's pace over two hundred years. But I want to tell you that with Iranian students' intelligence, faith, sense of independence and the dignity now present among our people, especially our young people and students, there is hope that in thirty years they can achieve what takes others a hundred.

What is the best way to confront wrongdoing?

It depends on who is doing the confronting. For you, the means is speech. Beyond speaking, you have no further duty. For ordinary people, forbidding wrong is verbal only. The government is different. In cases of grave wrongdoing, its response may at times be legal and severe. But the injunction to enjoin good and forbid wrong, as it applies to you under Islamic law, is expressed through speech: “It is only the tongue.”

Do not be surprised. I tell you that verbal encouragement and admonition, if actually practiced, can be more effective than the iron fist of governments. For several years I have called for enjoining good and forbidding wrong. Some do it, but not everyone. Many have not tried it and still ask why it has no effect. Try it. When you see something wrong, speak up. Your words need not be biting, nor must you deliver a speech to correct it. Simply say, “Sir, madam, brother, this is wrong.” You say it, a second person says it, a third, a tenth, a fiftieth: who can continue the wrongdoing then?

But my dear ones, you must recognize wrongdoing correctly. Something may appear wrong to certain people without actually being wrong. You must know what is good and what is wrong, and be genuinely sure it is wrong. Some say there must be a possibility that admonition will work. I say this possibility exists everywhere, except perhaps with tyrannical governments, powerful oppressors and monarchs, who do not listen to reasonable words. Ordinary people, however, are influenced by words. So my answer to you is that your best method is speech.

In view of the cultural assault on universities, the despotism and monopolistic attitudes of certain faculty members, and pressure on and exclusion of Muslim professors, what measures does the system envisage to protect Muslim academics from dismissal?

I do not confirm the statements that you, my dear brother or sister, have written and that I have read. Reading them aloud does not signify agreement; I am quoting you, and I do not know whether such things are happening. Of course, if a university environment really makes life difficult for Muslim professors, that would be bad and unacceptable. But I find it unlikely. I hope it is not happening.

Please give your opinion on solidarity among different groups.

I believe in solidarity and good relations, though good relations do not mean abandoning what one knows to be right and certain. I believe student groups of every persuasion should maintain good relations. Look at countries and different social and political groups around the world. Despite major disagreements, they sit around a table, talk and negotiate, and eventually reach some result. It makes no sense for people in an Islamic university who share basic principles—who believe in Islam, the Imam, the revolution and its values—yet have different tastes, to be unable to get along. I cannot understand or accept that.

What is your opinion of civil society, the formation of political parties, and elections for councils?

“Civil society” is an expression; its meaning depends on how it is defined. Our president has raised the slogan of civil society, and in explaining it he said he meant a society modeled on the City of the Prophet, Medina. All of us are prepared to give our lives for such a society; that is clear.

Of course, the term has a particular meaning in the West today. You should know that Westerners seek by every possible means to transmit the fundamental lines of their own thought and culture. They have fashioned a particular model and given it a name; that is their affair. For us the expression has been given a meaning of our own, and we accept that meaning.

As for parties, council elections and so forth, the Constitution has defined all these matters. How could anyone refuse to accept the Constitution? It specifies the role of councils and political parties. I support and believe in implementing what the Constitution, and where applicable ordinary laws, provide.

I would like your opinion of groups that support religious guardianship (velayat).

I believe all groups support velayat. I know of no significant group in this country that rejects it; everyone accepts it. Some may have more love and devotion, others less. For example, we all accept the guardianship of the Imams, peace be upon them. One person hears the name of the Commander of the Faithful and immediately fills with tears; such a person has greater love and naturally receives greater reward. Another believes in him as Imam, is devoted and would even give his life for him, but does not begin weeping whenever someone says, “Peace be upon you, O Commander of the Faithful.” You cannot accuse that person of rejecting guardianship simply because his eyes did not fill with tears!

All student groups, collectively and individually, have contact with me, come to see me, and express devotion to velayat. They all accept it; of course they do. In a sense I support them all—not financially, for I do not give financial support to anyone. I believe these groups should be present in universities, work and strive, and help people become more Islamic and revolutionary. Their responsibility is to devote themselves to strengthening the Islam and revolutionary character of the different people around them—though they are already Muslims—and to advance them by fostering moral refinement and deepening ethical and revolutionary foundations.

What makes a successful student?

In my view a successful student is one who studies well, cultivates good character and exercises properly. I have three criteria for a successful student. The standards for a successful young person at home, a successful merchant or office worker may differ. But success specifically as a student requires good study, attention to ethics and self-improvement, and physical exercise.

What is the duty of faithful, Hezbollah-minded young people when they encounter deviations and ill intentions in some places?

If it is wrongdoing, their duty is to forbid the wrong.

Please tell us something about your youth.

In one sense my youth was very exciting and full of adventures; in another, it was not a youth one would long to relive. Believe me, someone who did not enjoy the kind of youth you have now has reason to envy you. My dear ones, you live in a time of freedom and opportunities for talents to emerge; our youth was not like that.

Once I came to the front of this university's Faculty of Law to wait for a brother with whom I had arranged to meet and go somewhere together. I stood there perhaps ten minutes. I felt the suspicious gaze of the ever-present SAVAK agents and the university's intelligence and security personnel. I was not a student, and they were probably asking themselves: what is this turbaned man doing in front of the Faculty of Law? Whom is he meeting, what does he want, and what are his intentions? Might he be engaged in political activity?

It was in the late 1960s or early 1970s; I do not remember exactly. At that moment the late Riazi Yazdi came across me. He was a fairly good poet employed by the Faculty of Medicine; I recently saw that his collected poems have been published. We were close friends. He called my name and greeted me, then asked whether I had seen the university mosque. I had not, so he offered to show it to me. I think it was around here, though I do not remember precisely. Perhaps the mosque was later altered, for there used to be inscriptions bearing poems. He led me to them and said, “Look at these verses,” and began reciting them. After reading to the end we discovered that he himself had written them! May God have mercy on him; he had brought me there to see his poems. We had enjoyed his poetry before, and here was another example. In any case, the atmosphere was dangerous and full of suspicion. I had been active in the struggle and had been imprisoned; yet simply standing outside the Faculty of Law for ten minutes brought the oppressive, suspicious looks of the agents upon me. Life was bitter.

How do you assess the role of the Office of the Representative of the Supreme Leader in universities? Is it fulfilling its paternal, nonpartisan role above factional and organizational divisions?

It is a very good institution, and universities needed it. It existed before my tenure, but I made some revisions, bringing in younger and more active people. From some universities I receive very encouraging news, thank God. Students from other places, however, come to complain. Brothers have complained to me many times; not about misconduct by the office's representative but, for instance, inadequate work, failure to act on time, and so on. Any problems must be corrected.

What will be the final outcome of the municipality case?

You must ask the judiciary, because I have no involvement in it and do not currently know the status of the case. At one point, when a deadlock arose and I genuinely saw a serious problem, I intervened temporarily to resolve it, out of regard for those involved. I saw that senior national officials on the different sides were running into difficulties, so I stepped in and found a temporary solution. That was not a final settlement. There is a case, it will go to court, and the outcome will become clear. I do not think a court proceeding is bad; it is a good thing.

On Sunday this week I witnessed a cleric being injured by someone on Kargar Street. In your view, what explains the decline in the clergy's popularity since the revolution?

You witnessed a cleric being injured, whereas I have virtually witnessed the martyrdom of several clerics. There is nothing especially strange about it; anyone may have enemies. A cleric was injured on a street, but at the same hour dozens of non-clerics may have been injured here and there. That does not prove diminished popularity. Nor can one generally say that the clergy's popularity has risen or fallen since the revolution. Some have become more popular, some less. At some stages their standing rose markedly; at others it fell a little. It depends on circumstances and developments of the time. Many factors influence the matter. This is ordinary.

I should add that a person regarded as holy may preserve his sacred reputation and almost heavenly image by standing aside and never involving himself in anything. But as soon as he enters a field of action, some will agree with him and others oppose him. If clerics had not taken part in various activities—as they did in revolutionary committees and other institutions at the beginning of the revolution—but had stayed in the mosque, occasionally nodding their heads and criticizing conditions, many people would surely have liked them. Yet once a person enters the arena, my dear ones, he always gains both supporters and opponents.

There are two attitudes. Some say it is better to remain a saintly figure, keep to the sidelines and interfere in nothing. Others say: I shall give up that saintly image, enter the field and carry out what I regard as my duty. Some will like it, others will not; what matters is that God approve. That is the attitude of those who act rightly. But not everyone acts alike. As the saying goes, “Many a cloak deserves to be burned.” I make no general claim that everyone wearing clerical dress holds an exalted position. No: many people, under this or any other beautiful, pure or sacred garment, may conceal an impure inner self.

In your opinion, what are the obstacles to implementing Islam's enlightened commandments and the progressive principles of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic?

Many have been implemented; we cannot say absolutely nothing has been done. But you are right that some laws remain unimplemented. There is not one single obstacle I could summarize in a sentence. The obstacles are varied: some concern performance; some arise from accumulated and serious weaknesses in management and management methods themselves; and some reflect unfavorable conditions inherited from the past or propaganda directed against these provisions or the Islamic Republic. There are many different obstacles.

Do you regard revolutionary action in the cultural sphere as advisable? In other words, when officials neglect their duties, do you approve of physical intervention against vice and immorality?

No. Under religious law you are in no way obliged to use physical force to confront wrongdoing; your obligation is simply to speak. Say what you have to say. You remain silent because you imagine speaking will not work. Try it; speak, and do so repeatedly. Naturally a single person's words may have little effect; encourage others to speak as well. Speech itself is far more effective than punching, and sometimes more effective even than a frown, though a frown can be constructive, unlike a punch. In any case, if physical intervention is necessary to forbid wrong, that is the government's responsibility, not the people's, unless the government authorizes and commissions someone. That is another matter, and we are not in such a situation today. We do not appoint people to do that, and we do not consider such arrangements advisable.

What will happen concerning clerical dress for students of Islamic studies seminaries?

I do not understand what is meant. What about the clothing? If a seminarian is also a university student, what happens to his dress? He can attend in his clerical clothing; there is no problem. Clothing makes no difference. If that was the intended question, I have answered it.

What is your view of the proposed “Adaptation of Medical Affairs to Religious Law” plan?

I have not seen this plan at all and did not even know of its existence. I learned from the newspaper controversy that such a proposal existed, with supporters and opponents. I do not know what it contains or how it works. In fact I deliberately do not express opinions on draft laws and regulations, because they have a legal process that should run its natural course. Once something becomes law, of course, I obey it, and everyone is obliged to do likewise. In any case, if the purpose is to observe Islamic standards in universities, that is good and indeed necessary. Any defects in the plan should be corrected.

First, we have pledged to remain faithful to our covenant with Imam Ruhollah and our beloved martyrs, and God willing we shall. Second, our question is this: universities today lack organizations capable of attracting at least forty percent of students, as you have said they should. Why do the system's thinkers not offer a model for recruiting members and producing cultural work through these organizations?

I do not think student organizations should take their model from outside; they do not need one. When I say they should attract forty percent, I mean that the existing student groups themselves should work well enough to attract at least forty percent of students. I believe they are not doing enough. Otherwise they could genuinely attract forty percent, or even a majority, of students. Insufficient effort, poor judgment, and sometimes negligence prevent it. As for what model to use, the students themselves must discover it.

In our Islamic system, can we regard one person as wholly right and another person or idea as wholly wrong, or does every person and school of thought contain some mixture of truth and falsehood? I regard this as a fundamental question for myself and many students.

Relativism of this sort is not a sound position. I do not mean to identify particular people as absolutely right or absolutely wrong. Naturally we recognize that there is no human being whose collection of ideas contains no mistaken opinion or false thought, even unknowingly. Likewise someone following a false idea probably says some things that are true. Even a liar tells the truth occasionally, if only by accident! I accept that. But to turn this observation into a philosophical principle and assert that absolute truth and absolute falsehood do not exist is wrong. They do exist.

At the Battle of Badr, the Prophet addressed the Lord of the universe saying that all truth stood that day against all falsehood. And so it did: the Prophet was absolute truth and the opposing side absolute falsehood. Where was the truth in that group of Quraysh unbelievers who lacked knowledge and morals, buried their daughters, bowed before idols, oppressed one another and committed so much killing? They represented absolute falsehood, just as the Prophet represented absolute truth. I therefore reject the theory of relativism regarding truth and falsehood. Whether any of us in actual life embodies absolute truth or falsehood is a different matter. I too believe that a person or group supporting truth can contain traces of error, falsehood or mistake, and the reverse can also be true.

I hope I have answered the question. If the dear brother or sister who wrote it still has questions, please write them down and submit them. If I later find the time, I shall answer them myself or arrange for a group to do so, and we can explain further.

Please state your opinion about the different positions taken toward the election to the Assembly of Experts.

I do not know what differing positions are meant. In any case I consider the Assembly of Experts election important. Unlike the president or Islamic Consultative Assembly, the Assembly of Experts does not have constant day-to-day work; its members wait for a particular moment. But that moment—choosing the Leader—is extremely important. I have received no written guarantee from God that I shall still be alive ten days, one month, six months or a year from now. I have no guarantee; I could be gone an hour from now. That is entirely possible, and I am not being rhetorical. Experts must therefore be ready to appoint another leader as soon as this one falls, just as they acted promptly after the Imam's passing. Quite apart from whom they chose—I consider myself insignificant—the act itself and its speed were extremely valuable in resolving a grave difficulty. That is why the Experts' work is important. Trustworthy, capable people should be elected and remain ready. They also meet once a year to discuss matters, which seems necessary and useful. Many years may pass without a need for their principal decision, but in the moment they must make it, this Assembly becomes tremendously important. That is my view; I know nothing about whatever other positions may exist.

As you have said, when the elite go astray the ordinary people are led astray too. Some people, directly or indirectly within your area of management, commit violations. How can we bring these to your attention?

You should know that it is now easier to bring a matter to my attention than to that of any other official in the country. If someone wants to inform me but does not, that is their own fault. I meet people frequently and have considerable contact with the public. On Mondays, by prior appointment, many people from various places and walks of life come to see me. Students and others attend; I hold many meetings. My office also has a public-relations division receiving hundreds of letters daily—I do not know the precise number. They summarize the letters and bring me the summaries every day in a booklet or, as you might call it, a bulletin. I review as much as time permits. It is therefore possible to convey such matters.

Who should put an end to the atmosphere of rumor-spreading that has developed in society?

I am not sure whether rumors can ever be eliminated completely. Rumors exist in every society. But if people targeted by them respond intelligently and the media disseminate accurate information, I believe the conditions that nourish rumors will largely disappear on their own.

On the day of the presidential election on May 23, what did you mean when you said, “Nobody is like Hashemi to me”?

The reason is that Mr. Hashemi and I have worked together and been friends since 1957—forty-one years. Forty-one years of friendship is a long time, twice your age! There is an interesting coincidence. When I said those words, Mr. Khatami had not yet been elected. Yet Mr. Khatami happens to have nearly as long a history with me, going back to 1958. He was young then. In 1958, when I was preparing to go to Qom, his father, the late Ayatollah Khatami—a dear and distinguished man—was in Mashhad and we met him there. Mr. Khatami and his brothers were fifteen or sixteen, while I was only five or six years older, a noticeable difference at that age. So we have known each other for a long time too. In any event, relations are good now. Our president is very close to us, and thank God our relationship is excellent and cordial.

What is your opinion of giving war veterans, Basij members and self-sacrificing participants priority for university entry and higher studies? Should this preference for devoted revolutionary forces still apply?

What is wrong with it? I see no problem. The Commander of the Faithful said, “Do not treat the benefactor and the wrongdoer as equal.” Those who genuinely served the revolution and the country went to the frontiers and fought while we stayed home and slept. What is wrong with giving them some priority?

Of course, such priority must in no way override academic standards. They must meet the necessary academic rank; an unqualified person must not enter university. Fortunately that has been the practice. Two or three years ago I received a report that some students admitted under these quotas held very high academic rankings. That is how it should be. In any case, I regard this preference as a good thing. It is an acknowledgment of sacrifice.

Please give your views on the future of students' political activities and the direction these activities should take.

I have spoken about this. Three or four years ago I said students should become politically aware and active, and I spoke sharply against those who had kept politics away from universities. A year later, or around that time, I said at a student gathering: do not misunderstand me. Political activity does not necessarily mean activity against the government, officials or the system. Some ill-wishers interpret it that way, as though political activity meant political gamesmanship. It is deception to imagine that political activity in universities can only consist of disparaging, abusing and insulting people. No. The purpose of political activity is to develop students' capacity for political analysis. A student without that capacity can be deceived, and a deceived student is a painful and difficult thing to witness. To acquire analytical ability, students must be politically active. They should read, write, speak, negotiate and debate about politics. Without this they cannot gain that ability. My conviction remains the same.

Please explain in greater detail the characteristics of an Islamic university as you envision it.

I have given several speeches on the subject; it cannot be explained in two words. Briefly, I regard an Islamic university as one where knowledge is recognized as a genuine value. A person does not study merely to earn a crust of bread. Consider the Prophet's saying: “Seek knowledge even in China.” Under the conditions of that age, he meant that if acquiring knowledge required traveling from the Hejaz to China, one should go. For what salary or income would someone in those days have undertaken such a journey by camel or ship? Could such an effort have been motivated simply by material earnings? The point is that knowledge has intrinsic worth. That attitude must exist in an Islamic university.

You must love knowledge, value it, and pursue it for God's sake with pure intentions. At the same time, my dear ones, you must cultivate your souls and strengthen your ethical foundations. A learned person, investigator, researcher or genius is a tremendous asset to a country—but only if he possesses firm moral foundations and a living conscience. Otherwise his knowledge will be of no benefit.

You know how many students received an education in our universities under the previous regime. Many were talented, but afterward they left the country and became servants of foreign governments working against their own people. They ate this nation's bread and studied in its universities, then went abroad to serve those governments and remained there for the rest of their lives. That is the consequence of lacking an awakened moral conscience. Those are a few brief points; a detailed explanation would take an hour.

In Ramadan of 1997 I went to Mecca with Mr. Aboutorabi. Visiting the House of God caused a revolution within me. I believe employing professors of basic sciences, technical subjects and engineering in jurisprudential discussions could offer new perspectives on religious questions, especially theology. Professors eager to undertake the tamattu Hajj in Mecca should also be able to enjoy that blessing.

Well, you say you went to Mecca and even found the way to do so—with Mr. Aboutorabi—so why ask me? Apparently Mr. Aboutorabi holds the key! I wish he could take me to Mecca too. In my entire life I have made the pilgrimage only once, for ten days, including the outward and return journeys. Thank God you went and stayed a full month; surely you enjoyed a greater spiritual benefit than I did.

As to drawing on professors and different sciences in jurisprudential discussions: strictly speaking, theology, or knowledge of God, belongs to kalam rather than jurisprudence. Nevertheless, such cooperation is a sound and excellent idea. It means using specialized knowledge to understand the subject matter to which rulings apply.

One major weakness in our jurisprudence is inadequate knowledge of the subjects of rulings. A jurisprudential ruling is a general judgment applied to a particular subject. If the jurist does not understand that subject, he may misunderstand or misapply the ruling. For example, in financial affairs some people do not understand money, bank credit or banking, and consequently misunderstand the Quranic prohibition of usury and may issue a different ruling. That is one example; there are many more. Studying subjects thoroughly is excellent, and I welcome it. The way forward is to establish links with the seminary in Qom. It would be good if Mr. Aboutorabi also helped put these interested colleagues in contact with the Qom seminary and its administration.

Please identify the political and cultural priorities in universities and the correct ways for revolutionary Muslim student movements to pursue them.

I believe I have already addressed politics. In my view today's political priorities should determine methods, not prescribe particular subjects; the subjects themselves do not differ much. Political debate among students is good, provided it is exploratory and investigative, not authoritarian or imposed from above. We criticize officials or personalities who issue pronouncements as commands, yet suddenly find a student delivering exactly such pronouncements at a small or large gathering! If issuing decrees is wrong, it is wrong everywhere. Student discussion must be open, expandable, flexible and capable of revision and adjustment, so that students develop the ability to analyze politics. That should be the goal of student political debates. The same applies to cultural questions. A detailed discussion would take far too long.

Islamic student organizations and cultural institutions frequently cancel out one another's work. Much of their time is devoted to answering one another politically and attacking each other rather than addressing cultural issues and society's real problems. Sometimes, claiming to act for God's sake, they even commit grave sins in the process! Please comment if you consider it necessary.

I think the way the issue is stated already contains its answer. Everything our concerned brother has listed is painful and wrong. They must not fight each other, undermine one another's work, attack one another, seek revenge or behave unpleasantly toward one another. That is how Muslim young people should conduct themselves.

Some cultural, social and economic activities in our society seem to lack a scientific basis. Student participation in certain matters could quite easily prevent problems and sometimes wastefulness and extravagance. How do you assess students' role in national and social participation generally?

Students are among the most lively, active and energetic groups. They should participate just as energetically in social and political affairs. It is very good for students to be active in different public matters: political issues, elections, marches and public positions, especially positions on important global and international issues. As for your point that some activities lack a scientific basis, it would certainly be good for them to have one. I have no further opinion on that particular claim.

What is the most important duty of faithful, revolutionary, Hezbollah-minded young people?

As we are discussing students, I believe revolutionary university students should study well and strive to improve their thinking and knowledge. They should seek to influence their own surroundings, be active rather than passive, and exert an intellectual and spiritual influence. It is possible. Sometimes a young person can influence an entire circle—the classroom, the professor and even the university—through the force of a spiritual personality. That is not achieved through political maneuvering but through spirituality, sincerity and a strong relationship with God. My dear ones, take your relationship with God seriously. You are young; value it, speak to God and ask of Him. Supplication and prayer—prayer with heartfelt attention—are essential for you. Do not push them to the margins.

I am a second-year university student with a strong interest in Islamic sciences, and I want to become an Islamic scholar and preacher. Some say to obtain my bachelor's degree before entering the seminary. What do you advise? Should I finish my bachelor's, master's or doctorate first, not enter the seminary at all, or enter it now?

Some university students have gone to the seminary, pursued religious studies and attained high levels, and that has been very good. Some, I think, entered after completing their undergraduate degrees; others after graduate studies. Still others are seminarians while also attending university. They are doing very well, although it is somewhat difficult.

As for the brother who says he is interested, I think he should assess his abilities, enthusiasm and talents. It is impossible to judge from a distance. I apparently have not met you and do not know your abilities, so I may not be qualified to advise specifically. If you are genuinely enthusiastic and your present field does not interest you, you could leave it and go now. However, since you have taken the university entrance examination, enrolled, and probably completed several terms, it would be a pity not to finish. I would recommend completing your studies and obtaining at least a bachelor's degree. But if your enthusiasm is not particularly strong, or you are uncertain, continue your studies for now and make the decision later.

Peace be upon you, and God's mercy and blessings.

 

Cultural Invasion Political Gamesmanship Enjoining Good and Forbidding Wrong Islamic Society National Dignity Prophetic Civil Society Intellectualism Islamic University Cultural Jihad Scientific Progress in Iran Scientific Independence Recognizing the Right Moment Political Analytical Ability Faithful Revolutionary Youth