→ Back to search
1377/06/12 (Solar Hijri) 1998-09-03 (Gregorian)

1377/06/12- Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session at Tarbiat Modares University

1377/06/12

Remarks at a Question-and-Answer Session at Tarbiat Modares University


https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Thank you very much, and we are delighted by your visit to this university. As you know, alongside its physical development this university trains lecturers and professors. As a master's graduate and doctoral student here, I ask you to graciously undertake the cost of the university's sports hall as a blessing and auspicious gesture.
* The truth is that I have no personal money to give to the university; government funds are involved. I might be able to recommend something. I would be willing, if possible, to recommend that assistance be provided.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif As you know, reforming society requires reforming and strengthening its judiciary. The negative performance of judicial officials at various levels in recent years, and your support for them, have caused law graduates to despair of judicial reform. As a citizen with some familiarity with legal issues and the adverse impact of the judiciary's performance on people's belief in the system, I expect a fundamental reconsideration of this issue.
* Certainly I cannot deny weaknesses in the judiciary, but I do not share this dear brother's or sister's entirely negative assessment. There are, in fairness, many good accomplishments, outstanding efforts and honorable judges in the judiciary, alongside shortcomings. Know that I have always supported all three branches of government and will continue to do so. That is my duty. The heads of the three branches have my support as long as they hold office. This does not mean I approve of everything they do; certainly not. Things happen in the executive and legislature too that I may disagree with, but that is no reason to withdraw my support. The judiciary is no different. Do not reproach me for supporting it; I must support the heads of the branches of government. Of course, that support is public. In meetings, instructions and written notes there are criticisms, objections and orders to address particular matters. When changes are necessary and I can make them without improper interference in the work of a branch of government that might disrupt the system, I intervene. Sometimes we even speak sharply to certain people in private meetings. Nevertheless, I consider public moral support for all three branches necessary and will, God willing, continue providing it.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Greetings and wishes for victory and dignity for Islam and our dear fellow Muslims, especially Your Eminence and the other servants of Islam. In an Islamic society, presumably the most worthy and competent believers should hold positions of responsibility. Why, then, do some of those you appoint lack integrity, managerial ability and devotion to service? I ask that, to strengthen Islam and the front of religious guardianship, you appoint impartial, independent and capable people.
* Please know that I intend to place the best people in positions of responsibility; have no doubt about that. Even in the areas you mention—whose names and responsibilities I have not read aloud—I have tried to select the best. Of course choosing people is difficult. Someone looking on from the sidelines sees faults. Sometimes personal motives cause a fault to appear larger than it is, good qualities to be overlooked and comparisons among different candidates to become impossible. It is very difficult. We try to employ good, capable people. Sometimes we appoint people and later conclude they are unsuited to those positions; naturally we remove them. We know how to do that too. Appointments are not always permanent; there are dismissals as well. And dismissal takes two forms: sometimes it results from anger or dissatisfaction, sometimes from a considered judgment of what is best. Both occur.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif As the Leader of the Revolution, please take measures to prevent us from becoming trapped in the quagmire of Afghanistan.
* If you mean becoming drawn into the Afghan war, God willing that will not happen. I have taken particular care over this issue and, God willing, will continue to do so.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Please unite the forces of the Revolution in solving society's problems and help them avoid division, since our system must be responsive in both thought and action.
* Yes, you are right. I try to bring opposing factions closer in practice as much as possible. I do not try to merge them. I regard that as neither necessary nor possible, and perhaps not useful. But I do wish to bring them closer in their actions. Know, however, that it is not easy. Many motives are involved. If motives everywhere were truly sincere and devoted to God, matters would be much easier. Where motives lack sincerity, even in one corner, things become very difficult. Pray that we succeed; God willing, we too will make every effort.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Greetings and best wishes for your health and success. Our university system has no law governing transfers of faculty members. As a result, someone may have to live for many years in an unfamiliar and unwanted city, seriously undermining motivation. If possible, please arrange for factors such as length of service and other merits to be considered when people are transferred.
* This deserves the attention of government officials. I will set it aside so that they can examine it later, God willing, and consider a solution.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Why is no hiring priority given to Tarbiat Modares University graduates? Some universities treat applicants from this university with deliberate prejudice. My second question concerns the unsatisfactory living conditions of academic staff serving under the Ministry of Culture and Higher Education's military-service program. Why is nothing done to improve their situation?
* I had not been aware of the matter raised in your first question. This is the first time I have heard that graduates of this university encounter prejudice at other universities. If true, it would be genuinely regrettable. I shall set aside both questions for Dr. Moin so that, God willing, he can investigate the reasons and consider what can be done.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Since Mr. Khatami's respected government was elected by the people and has your approval, why do you, as Leader of the Revolution, not stop pressure groups from obstructing its constructive initiatives?
* If I see and know that someone is genuinely obstructing this government, rest assured I will stop them decisively, without hesitation. I believe everyone must help this government today; success will not be possible without that support. The country's challenges are very sensitive, and I have always urged everyone to help. I have freely given the president and cabinet whatever support they requested that was within my power, and will continue to do so. If people genuinely seek to cause trouble, I will intervene. However, some actions may merely express opposition and do not amount to obstruction. Governments always have opponents. There is nothing wrong with disagreeing on an issue or voicing criticism as long as it does not turn into obstruction. If it does, it will certainly be stopped.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Greetings, and thank you for visiting. Despite having passed ethical and academic screening and possessing both commitment and expertise, graduates still face difficulties in finding positions and completing university recruitment procedures. Please provide guidance to make this process easier.
* I do not intervene in administrative procedures. If I have one recommendation, it is that graduates of this university should at least be able to find employment throughout the country. The most favorable outcome would be to give them special consideration, since this university was established with particular hopes and giving its graduates some advantage would be appropriate. At the very least, however, obstacles should not be placed in their way. That is my general view. Since this point has now been raised repeatedly, I think our colleagues should give it greater attention.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Mr. Lajevardi's martyrdom was painful because he performed many services for the Revolution. After leaving office he was martyred by assassins in a headscarf shop. Should the Islamic government not offer reasonable protection to those who formerly served the sacred system? Will Mr. Khalkhali meet the same fate?
* I wish you had not suggested that idea to terrorists! I do not know whether Mr. Lajevardi had a bodyguard. I recently read in a newspaper that he himself did not want one. Indeed, if someone wishes to pursue a private occupation in the bazaar, bringing guards to and from work is not easy. I do not know exactly what the authorities should have done. Should they have prevented him from taking private employment or found another job for him? I have not really thought this through. Perhaps it is reasonable to say that people exposed to such risks should, after leaving their official duties, find employment in circumstances that do not expose them so easily to danger. In any case he was an outstanding figure. I knew him from the 1960s, before the Revolution. In my eyes, and in those of most involved in the struggle, he was a man of steel. As I wrote in my message after his martyrdom, he was someone who always appeared in the most difficult arenas and never shied away from hard work. May God elevate his station. His fate is indeed enviable; fortunate is he. When I heard of Lajevardi's martyrdom, I said it would have been a pity for a man with such a record to die an ordinary death; he should have been martyred. How fortunate he was.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif As you know, the important Assembly of Experts election is approaching. Unfortunately doubts about how the Guardian Council assesses candidates' qualifications have undeniably arisen. Would you not consider intervening, as Imam Khomeini sometimes did? After all, the Council's vetting of candidates seems to involve, to some degree, the circularity identified by critics. Would it not be better for the Guardian Council, on your recommendation, to refer the matter to religious authorities nominated by the Society of Seminary Teachers to dispel this suspicion?
* The Guardian Council does not itself administer the examinations; the examiners are other people. The Council supervises the process, for it has no time to sit and conduct examinations itself, though it certainly possesses the qualifications. Those currently on the Council—with one exception appointed during my tenure—were appointed by the Imam, who thereby attested to their scholarly competence in Islamic jurisprudence and their justice. So there is no basis for suspicion. These gentlemen do not conduct the examinations themselves. They enlist qualified, impartial teachers from Qom. As announced, the examinations are written, anonymous and without identifying headers. There is therefore no cause for doubt.

The argument about circularity is also mistaken. The present Guardian Council was not appointed by the current Leader, but by the preceding Leader. The incoming Assembly of Experts is not there to elect the current Leader; it will elect the next one. Where is the circularity? If the current Leader dies or leaves office for another reason, they will choose his successor. They are not choosing the current Leader. Thus no circularity exists.

As educated and learned people, praise be to God, you must think carefully about such matters. Every undertaking and examination has an authority responsible for it, and some may not accept that authority. What matters is knowing that the necessary competence exists. The examiners are respectable people, and those who oversee the examinations are qualified. God willing, no problem will arise.

Since we are discussing the Assembly of Experts election, I should say that it is truly important and distinctive. Broad participation is excellent and necessary for several reasons. At the very least, it is a national demonstration in the face of foreign enemies. You, as scholars and active young people, should encourage people to take part in the election itself. Of course people will participate on their own and, God willing, elect qualified candidates in every city and province. This election should be broad and successful.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Thank you for coming to this university. Given the importance of the Assembly of Experts and the unexpected silence currently evident in society on the eve of its election, do you think it appropriate to urge broad popular participation and public enthusiasm, particularly by asking the Guardian Council to make the necessary preparations?
* Yes, I think it appropriate. God willing, what I have just said here will be broadcast and published. Whenever necessary I will give further recommendations. The Guardian Council must prepare the ground, as must radio and television, and—as I have said—you young people have a role. Work toward this so that, God willing, the outcome will be good.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Greetings and condolences on the days commemorating Fatimah. Without offering any opinion of my own, I request that, to preserve the standing of your representative office at ... University, you order an investigative team to be sent there.
* Very well. I will put this note in my pocket so that, God willing, some action can follow.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif We request a serious and comprehensive review of whether representative offices are necessary at universities. By sending seminarians and people with only minimal religious knowledge, do you not think academics will form an impression that religious seminaries have a low intellectual standard? Do you not think these offices, unable to present persuasive arguments to university people, invoke your authority excessively?
* I do not believe that these brothers serving at universities are, as the question says, “at the lowest academic level.” Some whom I know are very good. I do not know everyone, since I do not personally appoint these brothers. I appointed the central board several years ago, and I trust them; they are distinguished individuals. Some of the people I know serving at universities are very good. Admittedly, several years ago there were complaints. But under the new arrangements that have existed for three or four years, there are good, learned young people in universities. Some are both students and seminarians; others are accomplished seminarians, and still others distinguished teachers. It is not as this brother or sister writes, that they are “at the minimum level.” If the writer specifies in another letter exactly where the standards are so low, I will certainly investigate through a reliable channel and, if that is indeed the case, alert the responsible brothers. But I do not think it is.

Regarding the necessity of these representative offices, when we established them everyone considered them necessary, and there were many requests for them. That remains true today. Some have, of course, told me that they are unnecessary. If the university environment already provided the principal objective of these offices—religious education and a reliable center for seeking religious guidance—I would not have established them; there would have been no need. But since that provision is lacking, these brothers are necessary. They can be a source of many blessings in universities. Young people have religious questions and needs, and having a learned young cleric of their own generation nearby is very valuable. That is how I see it.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif In an overall analysis, Mr. Khatami's election was a vote for reform, provided a golden opportunity to strengthen the system and secured the Islamic Revolution for years to come. In these circumstances: (1) Why are your appointees in ... chosen from factions opposing this trend? (2) Do you too consider it insulting or undermining to remind people of the Assembly of Experts' duty to supervise the Guardian Jurist?
* The phrase “vote for reform” is this brother's or sister's interpretation, not mine. Twenty million people voted for the president for various reasons. How do you know all twenty million voted for reform? They had different motivations and voted accordingly. What is certain is that this president was elected by twenty million people, and that is valuable. But unless you held a referendum among those twenty million and they told you they voted for reform, I cannot accept that assertion.

Of course everybody wants reform; no one opposes all reform. Nor does anyone believe everything was perfectly sound before this government. Certainly there were many shortcomings. When you elect a president you expect him to address them. There is no doubt about that; everyone thinks and hopes so. In any future election it will be the same: some people approve of particular things and others do not.

As for the claim that my appointees in various institutions oppose this process, no, I do not accept it. They too favor reform. The individuals named in this note—whose names I shall not repeat—support reform. Many are fond of the government and Mr. Khatami himself and cooperate with him. In my view such judgments are rather speculative and inappropriate.

On the question “Do you find it insulting to remind the Assembly of Experts of its duty to supervise the Guardian Jurist?” I say no—what insult? The Assembly of Experts has an Investigation Committee, operating under the Constitution itself. Its job is to examine whether a Leader whom the Assembly previously judged to meet the conditions still meets them. That is precisely its function, and the committee exists and works today. It must determine whether the Leader still possesses the knowledge and competence in Islamic jurisprudence found at his appointment, since a person could lose his memory and thus become unqualified. He was judged just then; does he remain just? If, God forbid, he commits a sin, he loses the required justice. They concluded he was capable of sound management and judgment; does he remain capable? Were they mistaken originally, or has he since lost those abilities? No, I feel neither weakened nor insulted. This is part of the Constitution. I myself belonged to the Assembly of Experts during the Imam's lifetime, when we too had an Investigation Committee. There is no problem. This neither insults nor weakens the leadership. Indeed, if the members failed to form such a committee, they should be asked why they had not done so.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif If we recognize education, research and moral cultivation as the university's three great missions, the formative mission, which takes precedence, is closely tied to the Supreme Leader's representative institution and cultural councils. Unfortunately, some of those serving in these bodies seldom tolerate dissent; some belong to particular factions. At certain universities, almost all the members of educational, research and cultural councils are the same people, effectively excluding others. Please clarify our legal and religious duty.
* If they cannot bear to hear opposing opinions, may God give them patience to listen! It is difficult, of course. I myself served eight years as president and have held my current responsibilities for eight or nine years. Contrary to the popular notion that visitors merely praise and flatter us, most of them bring complaints. They criticize me personally, or my appointees—as some of you are doing in these notes—or the government, which they regard as my responsibility, or conditions generally, which they also attribute to me: poverty here, weakness there, lack of development elsewhere. I hear such things constantly, and I know how hard this is. From a distance you cannot appreciate its difficulty. Listening to and tolerating opposing views is not easy.

Nevertheless, anyone who accepts responsibility must also be tolerant. The brother running a university representative office must develop this quality. I do not expect him to have as much patience as I do, but he must have as much as his responsibility requires. There is no doubt about that.

As for whether they belong to a particular faction, I do not know. Unfortunately, talk of factions and political lines has become far too pervasive. To some extent it is harmless—a little spice in the system! People describe themselves proudly as right-wing or left-wing. I do not like these labels—right, left and the like. When they penetrate every part of life, they become tiresome and unpleasant. We should not place too much emphasis on factions and such matters.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Since Mr. Khatami's election, the academic and political environment of universities has improved in the direction of Islamization, offering brighter hopes. Yet we remain far from the highest Islamic goals for universities. Greater support is needed for institutions, faculty members, students, postgraduate studies and all areas of science and research, but ministries have limited resources. What guidance can you offer?
* First, as a member of a medical university's faculty, you have written about these positive developments since Mr. Khatami's election. I thank you and am very pleased. We receive too little good news! When someone tells us something good has happened, it truly is a kindness, because it makes us happy from the bottom of our hearts. Praise be to God. We hope this flourishing will grow better every day. As for the shortcomings and limited resources, my answer is the same as to another note: this falls within the competence of government institutions. I will, of course, make the appropriate recommendation. I will set this letter aside to give to Dr. Farhadi.

https://farsi.khamenei.ir/themes/fa_def/images/ver2/li_star_1.gif Why do we not make proper use of our domestic scientific capabilities to solve problems? Why do we look abroad, to foreigners (unbelievers) and foreign capital instead of relying on our own committed and specialized minds? What harm came to the Revolution from trusting domestic forces during the Revolution and war that should make reconstruction different? Even if development is achieved by depending on foreigners, what pride is there in it? Tomorrow they will claim credit for helping us. Did our Revolution not triumph under the slogan “Neither East nor West”?
* I do not know what this brother or sister means by “dependence on foreigners.” We have never wanted dependence abroad. Today in reconstruction, architecture and infrastructure—dams, roads, railways, major factories and power stations—our own specialists accomplish things in this country that were once unimaginable.

Early in the Revolution, during my presidency, the idea arose of entrusting dam construction to our own engineers. Some protested: “Is that even possible?” It happened that I traveled to Khuzestan for another reason, and our brothers in Construction Jihad showed me an enormous grain silo with a capacity of forty or fifty thousand tons that they had built themselves. As I understand it, silo construction is comparatively complex architectural work. Previously the Russians built Iran's silos. The old regime bought its wheat from America and had its silos built by Russians! Iranian engineers did not even imagine undertaking such projects. There I saw that the young people of Construction Jihad, uncelebrated young people without impressive titles, had built something so substantial. It truly strengthened my confidence, and we pursued the matter. Today dams, roads, major infrastructure, factories and power stations have been and are being built within the country. In this sense we are not dependent on foreign countries at all.

If the question concerns foreign investment, that is authorized by law and the government is pursuing it. In our view there is no objection under the established conditions; it serves the country's interests. Foreign investment consistent with our laws is not bad and does not conflict with independence. Sometimes circumstances even make it necessary. We have not yet been particularly successful in attracting it; you should know that as well. The government is making great efforts to attract investment, but the desired results have not yet materialized. In any event, it is not a bad thing, and I see no reason for alarm on that score. We are proudly pursuing the expertise of our own faithful and specialized people.

Many questions from the brothers and sisters remain, but our time has run out and I am genuinely tired. I shall take the questions with me. Answering each one personally is almost impossible because I simply do not have the time or capacity. Nevertheless, I hope to ask several brothers to review them. They know my views and may be able, God willing, to prepare answers and send them to the university. The questions are unsigned, so I do not know how to distribute the answers or return them to their authors. We shall have to find a solution.

Today's meeting has been a good one. If I had not become tired I would have continued, but you must acknowledge that I have been speaking with you for an hour and forty-five minutes. May Almighty God accept this meeting, look upon it with pleasure, and accept through His generosity and grace everything we have said and heard and all our intentions as being for Him and in His cause.

Peace be upon you, and the mercy and blessings of God.
Reformism National self-confidence Meritocracy Production of knowledge Achievements of the Islamic Revolution Self-sufficiency Economic independence Freedom as a duty Public participation