→ Back to search
1377/12/15 (Solar Hijri) 1999-03-06 (Gregorian)

1377/12/15- Remarks to Participants in the Conference on Assessing the Vulnerabilities of the Revolution

1377/12/15

Remarks at a Meeting with Participants in the Conference on Assessing the Vulnerabilities of the Revolution

In the Name of Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful

First of all, I regard this gathering as a valuable opportunity. I am pleased to meet this precious group of students, professors, thinkers, and Islamic and revolutionary intellectuals. I thank you for giving this subject consideration and raising the question.

I had a little time to review the titles of the papers that had been submitted, as far as they were available in print. I did not have the chance to study them in detail, and I do not know whether I shall later. Nevertheless, I gained some sense of the nature of your program.

Your group’s work did not receive the attention it deserved on radio and television, although it was important: it was scholarly, concerned a current issue, and could lay the groundwork for useful future steps. Matters of this kind should be properly presented to the public, which did not happen. God willing, take the next steps more forcefully, broadly, and firmly so that people may benefit. I sincerely thank you all and everyone involved.

Let me not forget to thank the brother who recited a supplication between the two prayers. It was very good, and we benefited from it. Especially you young people should appreciate these supplications and their recitation: they guide both the mind and the heart. If you reflect carefully on their meaning, you will see how much intellectual guidance they contain, and what important teachings are embedded even in short supplications recited after prayers. We need these teachings, though we often overlook them. The lofty meanings of the words recited in prayer are among the things we need most. We truly need prayer—today, tomorrow, and always.

I reflected briefly on the question you have raised, and several points occurred to me which I wish to share. God willing, if these points seem as important to you as they do to me, you will pursue them in your future work.

First, examining the vulnerabilities of something—whether a revolution or a human being—does not necessarily mean examining injuries that already exist. We should not assume that discussing the vulnerabilities of the Revolution refers exclusively to problems that have already occurred. No: you must examine potential vulnerabilities, including those that exist now and those that might develop in the future. Likewise, identifying possible vulnerabilities should not lead us to conclude that they already exist. That would be an incorrect judgment, although some people would like to portray the Revolution as injured, ill, weak, and incapacitated.

Today, carefully planned media campaigns concentrate on portraying the Revolution as worn out, aged, weak, and unable to continue its journey. I say that this portrayal is contrary to reality. The Revolution is alive, and its capacity to move forward remains substantial. One must distinguish between the possibilities one studies as a precaution and the actual condition of the Revolution.
In any case, note that when we discuss the possible vulnerabilities of the Revolution, it does not mean that it has already been afflicted by all these conditions and lies sick and powerless. Certainly not. We are discussing dangers so that they can be recognized and prevented.

The second point is that assessing the vulnerabilities of any entity must take account of its strength. Some have weak constitutions: even the smallest virus can destroy them, because they lack defenses. Someone with AIDS may die from a minor cold virus because the body's defense system—its protective cells and white blood cells—has been disabled. For such a person, even a cold is a serious vulnerability, whereas cancer is not necessarily fatal for someone with a strong constitution. We have seen strong people fight cancer through chemotherapy and effective treatment, recover, and go on living. We must therefore assess the strength of the entity whose vulnerabilities we are studying.

I wish to tell you that our Revolution is immense, far greater and stronger than the assessments of international observers suggest. Its underlying strength is very great, as I will briefly explain. That is why, although the attacks, blows and blockades directed against it have exceeded those faced by any revolution I know, its vulnerability has been considerably less than that of the world's other great revolutions. I have made notes comparing our Revolution with three well-known revolutions, with which you are more or less familiar. Other examples exist, but these three are important.

One is the French Revolution, more than two centuries ago. Another is the Soviet Revolution, relatively close to us in time and among the greatest revolutions of recent centuries. The third is an Islamic revolution, the Algerian Revolution, which was truly a revolution. One cannot seriously regard many of the coups carried out in Africa and Latin America in the name of revolution as revolutions. I have visited some places where revolutions took place, African and other countries, such as Mozambique and Zimbabwe, and have also seen what happened in India, if indeed those events can be called revolutions.

We have observed these events firsthand. None possesses characteristics that would allow a genuine comparison with our Revolution. But those three revolutions are comparable to some extent. In my view, such a comparison would also be an excellent scholarly undertaking. How good it would be if people pursued it! It would be scholarly both in the sociological and in the historical sense.

Twenty years have passed since our Revolution. Consider the situation twenty years after the French Revolution, the October Revolution, or the Algerian Revolution. In France, twenty years after the great revolution—around 1809—the only change from the time of Louis XVI was the identity of the monarch. In 1809 Napoleon Bonaparte was ruling: an emperor who had crowned himself and was a monarch in the fullest sense. The popular vote and freedom for which the French Revolution had struggled were entirely absent from Napoleon's absolute rule. Another difference was that Louis XVI was an ineffectual king, whereas Bonaparte was a capable and powerful one.

What France can now cite as Bonaparte's achievement is his conquest of Italy, Austria, and Belgium. Those were his accomplishments. Otherwise, twenty years after the Revolution, his rule offered nothing that could be celebrated in terms of the Revolution's ideals—the ideas articulated by Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Voltaire, and others. If you examine what occurred in France during those twenty years, you will see that our great and glorious Revolution stands out above any such example.

During those twenty years in France, before Napoleon came to power, three groups held power, each in the name of the Revolution. The first were revolutionaries who committed those violent, blind, unforgettable acts and caused destruction recorded in French history; perhaps you have read or heard about them. In any case, they carried out a revolution and were, to some extent, tolerable.

After about five years a second group took power and purged the first. Nearly all the prominent revolutionary figures were executed. This second group were the extremists who accused the original revolutionaries of compromise and put them to death.

A third group then came and accused the second of extremism; they executed some members and exiled many others, and that exile continued for years.

If you have read Victor Hugo's Les Misérables, at the beginning of the story there is an elderly man who had been one of the representatives elected by that second group. Even by the time Hugo's story begins—roughly the late nineteenth century, around 1825, perhaps later—that exile still persisted. In the novel you can see the exile's story, what he did and said, and how he still lived in fear.

The third group, having accomplished its work, albeit very weakly, prepared the ground for Napoleon's rise. Taking advantage of his cleverness, his talents, and France's unsettled conditions, Napoleon rose to supreme power and restored the monarchy, though not the monarchy of the Bourbon dynasty to which Louis XVI had belonged. That situation lasted while Napoleon lived. After his death the same dynasty returned, with Louis XVIII and other Bourbon monarchs. France remained in turmoil for decades, almost a century after the French Revolution. These are extraordinary and significant historical events.

I regret that some of our young people are unfamiliar with these events! (1) You are right; I was actually about to say the same thing to radio and television, but you got ahead of me! Some of the blame lies with the education and instruction we unfortunately lack. Yet reading books is also not enough by itself; suitable books need to be written.

In short, a hundred years after the Revolution, France was like a ship tossed by waves. Numerous monarchs came and went. After Napoleon the Bourbons returned and departed again; eventually the Communists came to power and then lost it, until, after more than a century, the French Republic finally attained some measure of stability.

Now compare that with our situation twenty years after our Revolution. We are at the twentieth anniversary; look at what happened there and what is happening here!

Look at the Soviet Union twenty years after the October Revolution, in 1937. People of my generation remember that Stalin's dark dictatorship ruled the Soviet Union during those years. Hundreds of thousands were executed or destroyed for opposing his government, or merely being suspected of opposition. Many times that number were exiled to Siberia and suffered terrible fates. Almost without exception, the original leading figures of the Revolution were executed or driven into flight by their successors; some died in exile. In 1937 the Soviet Union was at the height of Stalin's oppressive dictatorship.

That dictatorship did not preserve the Revolution's foundations. Stalin was a genuine tsar, only not a member of the Romanov family. He was another individual, but an absolute monarch. I doubt any monarch who ruled from the Kremlin ever wielded power as absolutely as Stalin. He inhabited the same palace, enjoyed the same ceremony, facilities, and way of life.

The one thing Stalin kept from the Revolution was the high-buttoned tunic he wore as a uniform until the end of his life. As soon as he died, his successors—the few men around him—discarded even that. Nothing else remained; it was over. Only the name of the Revolution survived, though the 'workers' government' had been little more than a name even at the beginning. Such was the Soviet Revolution after twenty years.

I personally saw Algeria twenty years after its revolution. When I visited, some nineteen years had passed. Its condition was truly instructive. The Algerian Revolution was an Islamic revolution, a revolution of mosques and religious scholars. Like ours, it began in mosques, religious schools and seminaries. Yet Algeria never had a religious government, not even for one day. From the outset the French succeeded in spreading their own culture and customs, and an absence of religious belief, in Algeria, a country that had been under their influence and was emerging from colonial rule.

During my presidency, an important Algerian official came to visit me. He spoke to me in Arabic, but when he wanted to say something, he could not remember the Arabic word—even though Arabic was his language and he was a government spokesman. He thought for a while without success, then turned and asked his companion in French for the word. The companion supplied the Arabic term, and he continued speaking to me.

In other words, they had failed to preserve and revive even the Arabic language in Algeria—not religion, but Arabic and Arab identity, which they apparently valued greatly. There was scarcely any trace of Islam there. Their living conditions, both material and economic, were dreadful. Their agricultural and economic situation—everything—was truly very poor. Of course, they retained the outward appearance of a revolutionary government and adopted good positions on international political questions.

Only under President Boumediene, who came to power following the Revolution, did the Algerians take revolutionary positions in the sense of maintaining independence from America and imperial domination and supporting the Palestinian cause. After some years even that changed.

When I consider their circumstances, I remember making notes about this in my occasional diary entries; reading them now is very instructive. The arguments Algerian officials offered then to justify withdrawing their support for Palestine, and especially to move closer to America, resemble remarkably the arguments foreign radio stations continually try to implant in our minds as officials today. When one listens now to the BBC, Voice of America, or Zionist radio broadcasts, one hears attempts to place the very same arguments once voiced by Algerians on our tongues. Fortunately they have not succeeded, and they will not succeed.

They had accepted what foreign radio stations told them. Twenty years after the Algerian Revolution it was no longer revolutionary, Islamic, or religious. Moral and spiritual values were entirely absent, and there had been no material progress either. If the Soviets failed to improve people's lives, at least they achieved something notable in the space race. If the French failed to realize the principles of freedom and independence of their Revolution, they at least made conquests abroad. Those were not positive accomplishments, but as a historical matter people described Napoleon as distinguished for his military conquests. Even he was ultimately ruined, however, suffering catastrophic defeat in his war with Russia.

Thus, when we compare them, we see that twenty years later our Revolution has suffered none of the various afflictions of a great revolution like the French one, a much-publicized revolution like the Soviet one, or a supposedly Islamic revolution like the Algerian one. This demonstrates the strength of our Revolution.

What, then, do I regard as the source of this strength? I say that it comes from religious commitment and faith. I mean faith accompanied by religious practice and worship, not merely the abstract claim to be a believer while neither praying nor worshipping, remembering or attending to God, nor observing any of the religious duties, and merely saying 'we have faith.'

No, that is not the faith I mean. The Quran refers to that distinction: 'The Bedouins say, We believe. Say: You have not believed, but say, We have submitted.' That is submission, not genuine faith. Our people possessed Islamic faith.

Before the Revolution I repeatedly argued everywhere that our people, who were accused of lacking faith, were in fact believers. They believed in what they understood of Islam and were prepared to sacrifice for it, give their property and their lives, and endure hardship. Events proved that this was true. The Iranian nation was a nation of faith and, fortunately, remains so today. I shall later explain that this faith and devotion is the principal target of the Revolution's enemies. It is the inexhaustible source from which the Revolution has drawn strength and through which it has avoided so many dangers.

Another point is that any assessment of the Revolution's vulnerabilities must consider both internal and external factors. There are two extremes here, and I want to keep both my own mind and the minds of the people free from them. One is to emphasize external forces and neglect internal ones; the other is to emphasize internal factors and ignore outside influences. There are people who fall into each error. Both factors are genuinely present. If one examines the matter, one sees the external factor in the hostility of the Revolution's enemies.

Consider that when the French Revolution occurred, there were no powers in the world with the communications or organizational capacity to mount the sort of opposition familiar today. Later, when Napoleon began his conquests, Britain and others opposed him. British financiers, French and German lords, and major landowners were opposed, of course. But there was no cohesive, organized political power devising and conducting a coordinated political, military, propaganda, and psychological campaign against the Revolution.

As for the Soviet Revolution, when it occurred, some of Russia's enemies actually diminished. Russia had traditional enemies and was participating in the First World War; Germany was one of its enemies in that war. As soon as the Soviet Revolution succeeded, unlike our Revolution, upon whose victory war was imposed, its war ended. Soviet Russia temporarily withdrew from the First World War, abandoning its allies who were fighting Germany and the others. It completely evacuated the eastern front and suffered severe blows. This situation lasted roughly a year; towards the end of the war the Soviet Union reentered and shared in its benefits. Thus it did not face the same kind of enemies at that time.

What is important is that the opponents of the Soviet Revolution, whether political or economic, opposed its particular content. In our case, however, not only did the Revolution's enemies turn against it—those whose political interests were damaged, such as powers that had influence in Iran, and those whose economic interests were harmed, such as people who benefited from Iran, whether domestic or foreign—but so did the enemies of religion itself. They were people throughout the world who opposed religion in principle for long-term ideological and intellectual reasons. Consequently the Soviet Union was almost as hostile to our Revolution as America was, at least during the war, despite not having lost any established presence in Iran.

On the contrary, because its rival had departed and American listening installations along the former Soviet border had been dismantled, the Soviet Union ought to have thanked us, cooperated, and assisted us. Yet it did not. Why? Because religion threatened it. The establishment of a religious government, especially alongside its Muslim-populated republics, harmed Soviet interests as much as the Revolution and the loss of American companies' and advisers' influence harmed the United States.

You can see, then, that we faced two kinds of internal opponents. In the Soviet Revolution, capitalists, landowners, and similar people opposed it. Yet intellectuals who had not benefited materially from the old Russian regime eventually reached an accommodation with the new regime, which skillfully drew them in. Thus even intellectuals who had been dissatisfied for a time joined the new Soviet system and collaborated with it, writing books for it. Their works still exist. They were the same earlier intellectuals: novelists, poets, musicians, and others, all cooperating.

In Iran, however, some people who suffered no material loss at all from the Revolution opposed it solely because it established a religious government, because they resented and rejected religion. This is a noteworthy reality. The Revolution proclaimed and promoted religion and encouraged people to practice it, while those people, influenced by Western culture or various intellectual tendencies—or, as they put it, ideologies and schools of thought—had no affinity for religion and would not accept it. There were even governments without any colonial interests or the ability to pursue such interests which nevertheless opposed the Islamic Revolution because, for political or ideological reasons, they opposed religion. Hence these enormous forces were arrayed against our country, and that opposition continues today.

These are the external factors, all of which worked to weaken the Revolution. Do not imagine they sat idle. They made every effort, until a war began and all of them assisted our enemy in that war.

One task I consider obligatory is that you young people should at least read the history of the war. The history of the Revolution may seem a little further away, but study the more recent history of the war. Learn what happened during the eight years of the Sacred Defense in Iran.

During those eight years of war, the entire world—or all those able to intervene—helped Iraq. I may have mentioned before that we needed barbed wire and bought some abroad. Since the road through Turkey was closed for some reason, we had to bring it through the Soviet Union, but they refused to permit even barbed wire through. We needed RPGs in the war. Veterans know that an RPG is a simple, individual weapon, yet they would neither sell us these weapons nor permit others to sell them to us. Do you see what I mean?

The very people who treated us in this way supplied Iraq with the most advanced aircraft and military equipment and sent their finest military specialists to help Iraq construct, over years, the strongest defensive fortifications in the desert around Khorramshahr and the area between our border and theirs that Iraq occupied. As for America, of course the Americans also helped Iraq.

At the time we suspected—purely as a conjecture, without documentary evidence—that the Americans were supplying Iraq with satellite intelligence. I said so in Friday prayers, and others said so as well, although many did not believe it. Yet in the last year or two you have read and heard that the Americans did in fact give Iraq satellite intelligence during the war. What we had inferred from the circumstances turned out to be true.

Well, these hostilities against the Revolution continue today. Vast resources and sums of money are still being spent. Recently, because the Americans have grown somewhat more brazen, they have disclosed certain expenditures, while concealing much larger ones. For example, there is the twenty million dollars formally approved by their Congress, but they spend far more than that.

Organized propaganda campaigns are conducted against the Revolution, together with powerful press, political, and diplomatic efforts. Their operatives are also inside the country, and I count them among the external factors. By external factors I even mean those who take their inspiration from them and work against the Revolution at home, writing against it, plotting, or inflicting economic and political damage.

These factors must not be ignored. Anyone who dismisses them as imaginary, as some people seek to do, is like someone standing at night in a forest, surrounded by wolves waiting for a moment of inattention to tear him apart, who nevertheless says, 'I must be imagining it.' Very well, imagine it and go to sleep! No one will suffer the consequences but you. Calling it imagination does not make the real, lurking enemy disappear. That is one side of the issue.

The other side consists of internal factors: those within ourselves as revolutionaries and believers. These are not few; there are many. What I wish to say is that if we remedy these internal vulnerabilities, external threats will not be able to impose their will on us.

Consider how explicitly the Quran speaks about this: “That is because God would not change a blessing He has bestowed upon a people until they change what is within themselves.” A blessing God grants you will not be taken away unless you yourselves alter the conditions that made you worthy of it.

This principle is among the established teachings of our supplications. Anyone who studies the Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya and other prayers recognizes that God does not withdraw His favor unless we ourselves change the conditions. That is why we must examine our own actions before attributing all difficulties to outsiders.

Now I shall summarize the internal enemy—more precisely, the enemy within—in three things. I believe the various issues ultimately return to these three. I noticed, on reviewing your discussions, that some of these concerns were also raised there.

One is lack of faith, or weakness of faith. This is an internal vulnerability. Another is poor performance in every field, including communications and public information, where the role of radio and television deserves discussion. A third is worldliness: being preoccupied with material gain and personal enjoyment.

In my view, these three are the principal factors, and everything else returns to them. Any institution or individual that contributes to these three conditions harms the Revolution. Anyone who weakens the faith of the people is inflicting damage upon it.

Any institution engaged in consequential work is guilty of poor performance if it does not correct defects in that work. And when we speak of shortcomings, we do not necessarily mean treachery. A mistake, negligence, or failure to carry out a duty properly may also be a source of harm.

Likewise, any institution that encourages people toward worldliness, directing them to seek personal pleasure and selfish material benefit, is in my opinion contributing to the vulnerabilities of the Revolution and to the harm done to it.

I believe that you brothers and sisters gathered here can play important roles in university life with regard to some of the matters I have described. Work to make faith firm, profound, pure, and clear. Do not cloud or contaminate it, introduce misgivings and doubts into it, or fill people's hearts with uncertainty. It is no service to a person who possesses pure, strong, and firm faith to undermine that faith and sow doubt in it. No, there is no justification for doing so under the pretext that we wish to stimulate their thinking.

Certainly, strengthen people's faith with sound reasoning. If you want someone to think, if you truly want human thought to develop, help that person learn to reason and reflect deeply and to understand well. Do not help them become uncertain, wavering, and doubtful. Such conduct has no justification and is not religiously permissible.

During the time of the Imams, peace be upon them, there were many debates involving the Imams and their companions. Throughout these exchanges the aim of those defending the truth was to strengthen faith and dispel doubts, not to create new doubts. In universities, the spread of doubts should be answered with serious and robust intellectual work. We do not lack arguments or solid reasoning; we have immense intellectual resources. Of course, I do not believe that anyone who holds an incorrect view should be treated harshly. Be quite clear about that: absolutely not.

One thing that helps an erroneous idea take root is responding to it without intellectual argument. Some people enjoy making an absurd claim and then having someone rise up and insult them instead of responding, 'Your argument is mistaken for these reasons.' That is precisely what they want, because it relieves them of the burden of making a reasoned case. They can then adopt the posture of victims and claim, 'They will not let us speak.' Even today you see people make senseless assertions, and although nobody stops them or even answers them, they immediately cry out, 'They will not let us speak!' But who is preventing you? Speak; nobody has stopped you. Do you understand?

The point is that lack of faith must be confronted through reasoned, intellectual engagement. Thank God, this is both possible and practicable. Worldliness, too, must be resisted.

My dear ones, one of our slogans before the victory of the Revolution—not an official revolutionary slogan, but something we emphasized among friends with whom we thought, worked, and struggled—was simple living: living modestly and taking less pleasure in the attractions of this world. After the Revolution's victory we tried to continue following the same approach, slogan, and principle.

Our revered Imam embodied this very principle. Worldly distinctions meant nothing to him. Anyone could see that honors, attachments, and the trappings of this world had no value for that great spiritual man. You are, thank God, thoughtful and well informed, so I need not explain this at length. I am speaking of personal enjoyment. I do not mean that the country should refrain from development or rebuilding and improving the world. Opponents of Islam have always distorted this matter, insinuating that Islam opposes the world and therefore tells us not to develop it.

No, what is meant here is one's personal worldly life: do not pursue an indulgent lifestyle; live simply. The Commander of the Faithful, peace be upon him, personally lived in the most ascetic manner, yet he was constantly working, cultivating farmland, digging and supplying wells, struggling in God's cause, administering the country, heading a vast government, and making and implementing policy.

What I mean is setting one's heart on worldly possessions, which accounts for a substantial part of our troubles. Those of us who are government officials or religious scholars must be especially careful, because these two groups bear particular responsibilities. Someone once said, 'Woe to those who are both government officials and clerics!' Their difficulty is greater and their duty more demanding. The public rightly expects more of them, and God will hold them more closely to account because their conduct has greater effects.

We must be especially watchful, and others must be watchful too. Whether you are students, professors, or leaders, all of you should take care not to become trapped in the formalities and status symbols of worldly life or submerged in luxury and aristocratic habits. We should wish for everyone to enjoy the permissible adornments of the world to the extent that God has allowed.

Of course, 'Wealth and children are the adornment of worldly life,' and there is nothing wrong with them. There is nothing wrong with wealth, children, office, or similar things. The danger is becoming absorbed in them, making them one's main concern and goal, and confining oneself to the pleasures and outward status of worldly life. If these faults are corrected, we may hope, God willing, that no serious problems will remain.

I must also say that Islamic intellectuals, clerics, and university authorities—university presidents, deans, and professors—all have roles to play, as do you students, whose role is fundamental. Radio and television have a particularly sensitive and important responsibility as well. Broadcasting must genuinely fulfill its proper role in the fullest sense and free itself from the shortcomings it presently exhibits, whether in art, films, advertising, spoken programs, religious presentations, or similar areas.

God willing, the Almighty will help. 'Whoever is for God, God will be for him.' Whoever works for God will find God's resources, knowledge, power, and the laws of creation working in his service. 'God will surely help those who help Him.' This is an extraordinary statement: the emphatic wording conveys an oath and an insistence that God will, without doubt, help those who support His cause.

Fortunately, this Revolution possesses abundant life, vitality, and energy. Thank God, it lives through faith and will be able to ward off these harms. Even if problems and harmful microbes are present, it will, God willing, defend itself. Its constitution is strong. May God's grace and the attention of the Master of the Age—may our souls be his ransom, and may God hasten his relief—support us. And may you receive this trust intact and in good condition and pass it on, God willing, even stronger and better, to the next generation.

And peace be upon you, and the mercy and blessings of God.

1) One of those present said: Radio and television should address this issue.
2) A reference to Dr. Gholam-Ali Haddad-Adel as secretary of the conference.

The Masses and the Elites Sowing Doubts Internal and External Enemies Vulnerabilities of the Islamic Revolution Intellectualism Divine Assistance Conspiracy Theories The Great Islamic Revolution of Iran